Printable View
You do not appear to have any issue with the lack of Rider, Kurai, Garm, Len, Akiha, Kohaku, and Hisui, despite the fact that they are equally 'ignored'.
In any case, since you feel strongly about this, I would like to ask you for what contributions you believe Sakura could have made to the meeting, since I myself am drawing a blank on the matter.
This is a Grail War, and I doubt you want the possiblity of Sakura killing a child no older then 10 on her conscience do you Mike -.-
Well, there's no way Sakura would be getting involved in the war, but that doesn't mean she won't have an opinion on it. She's part of the team, so it makes no sense to exclude her. And, indeed, it also doesn't make sense to exclude Rider.Quote:
Originally Posted by burningclaw2
Hell, Sakura isn't even mentioned here. It's like she doesn't even exist, despite the fact that they've just decided to send Shirou off to (potentially) get killed. You'd think they'd at least have the courtesy to let her have a say in the decision on who to send, rather than keeping her entirely out of the loop and acting as if she doesn't even exist.
The entire premise of the Grail Works continuity is that Shirou et al go off to do dangerous things and potentially get killed. Am I giving Sakura (and any of the others) too much credit when I say that they should have accepted that as a fundamental part of their lives from here on out?Quote:
Well, there's no way Sakura would be getting involved in the war, but that doesn't mean she won't have an opinion on it. She's part of the team, so it makes no sense to exclude her. And, indeed, it also doesn't make sense to exclude Rider.
Hell, Sakura isn't even mentioned here. It's like she doesn't even exist, despite the fact that they've just decided to send Shirou off to (potentially) get killed. You'd think they'd at least have the courtesy to let her have a say in the decision on who to send, rather than keeping her entirely out of the loop and acting as if she doesn't even exist.
And I ask once again - what concrete, actual contribution in terms of opinions or decisions do you think Sakura would have made to the meeting had she been there?
Also, what makes you think she's being kept out of the loop? First thing they did after the meeting was for Shirou to tell everyone who wasn't present that he'd be going away for a while, and the basic details if they wanted to know. I didn't mention it in the same manner I didn't mention that he also ate dinner and took a bath. It's a fundamental part of his life by now.
Mike, you're not being fair when you read what you want to read when people honestly try to answer your questions.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike1984
The only person truly qualified to answer your question, the author, had in fact answered you as best as they could without spoiling their story's plot. Now remember, this is the Author's Word, so generally, that's how it is...as a reader, yes you can ask some more, tease some things out or help patch up any holes you find, but like Pure said, you crossed that line into harassment. No one, and I mean, no one, will take the effort to answer you properly if all they can expect from you is harassment, for some of us, you tend to end up as a plaything.
Remember Mike, relax, calm down, chill.
This is a fanfic written by someone else with their own ideas, their own goals, their own plans; don't stomp all over someone else's hard work with your own views, don't look at everything as something targeted at you or your interests.
You have your answers, take off your blinds and read them properly this time.
It's a shame you're always like this man, you're otherwise a pretty cool guy.
=============================
On topic:
I wonder if 'Nero' is from Grail Wars...
I'm sure Sakura accepts that Shirou, Rin etc. going off to do dangerous things and getting killed is a possibility, but that doesn't mean she should be excluded from the meetings when they decide such things. And, whilst I'm not convinced Sakrua would have had much to contribute to the meeting, that doesn't mean she shouldn't be there. When you're planning a mission like that, it's not good to exclude members of the team because you don't know that they have something important to say. Indeed, nor does Rin, really.Quote:
Originally Posted by pureauthor
Plus, they're having a discussion. What's to say that Sakura wouldn't come up with some important insight? It's clearly more than just deciding who should go, they're planning out the entire job, and I see absolutely no reason why Sakura (and the rest) should not be part of that. Sakura is part of the team, not a general dogsbody who isn't important enough to have an opinion, like you seem to think.
Sorry, but it's just utterly ludicrous for them to have a team planning session without half the team. Yes, Sakura has nothing specific to add, but nor does Rin, and she's still there. She is perfectly capable of having an opinion, and I see absolutely no reason why she should be kept out and then just informed of the decision afterwards, as if she's not an important enough member of the group to be given the right to even have a say in how they operate.Quote:
Originally Posted by qsurf
And, honestly, the lack of Sakura in this chapter has nothing to do with the plot of the story. It's simply that he seemingly doesn't think she's important enough to warrant a mention.
They weren't "planning" anything. They were just deciding who will go. What input can Sakura possibly put into that decision?
They were discussing the situation and who to send. I see no reason why Sakura has any less of an "input" on that than e.g. Rin does. She's part of the group, she should have the ability to contribute to their decisions like everyone else, not merely be informed of them as if she were just some lackey who they use as a healer.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spinach
You know is it me or is extra saber in this fic actually
Spoiler:
which would explain why she isn't keen about revealing her identity
Rin is a candidate to go. That's why she's there. It's really as simple as that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike1984
Ilya called this meeting with a specific question in mind - who of the people present will be the one to go?Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike1984
It's not a brainstorming session where they toss out ideas and someone gets a flash of insight, it is a simple decision based on 'Who is willing and able to go, and likely to be able to resolve this problem.'
Recall that this was not put a vote - Shirou was chosen as the one to go on the basis of the fact that he is the person most suited to the task.
It is not a 'team planning' session. It is a 'Who will go' session, and frankly adding more people to the mix would only bog the decision making process down. Only the people who would potentially be going at all attended.Quote:
Sorry, but it's just utterly ludicrous for them to have a team planning session without half the team. Yes, Sakura has nothing specific to add, but nor does Rin, and she's still there. She is perfectly capable of having an opinion, and I see absolutely no reason why she should be kept out and then just informed of the decision afterwards, as if she's not an important enough member of the group to be given the right to even have a say in how they operate.
And, honestly, the lack of Sakura in this chapter has nothing to do with the plot of the story. It's simply that he seemingly doesn't think she's important enough to warrant a mention.
I understand that, but it just seems wrong to exclude half of the team from the discussion. They're treating Sakura like a second-class member just because she doesn't generally go out and perform missions.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spinach
I just find it extremely annoying that, as usual, people seem to be looking for excuses not to include Sakura, even when she is actually an integral part of the canonical setting.Quote:
Originally Posted by pureauthor
This isn't exactly the canon setting, you know.
I give up.
I look forward to the next update, Pureauthor.
In which case the crux of the matter appears to be that we have different opinions on how tasks such as these are supposed to be executed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike1984
Well, if it makes you feel better, I can tell you in all honesty that that is not the case in this particular story.Quote:
I just find it extremely annoying that, as usual, people seem to be looking for excuses not to include Sakura, even when she is actually an integral part of the canonical setting.
What do you mean?Quote:
Originally Posted by LeopardBear
Perhaps.Quote:
Originally Posted by pureauthor
However, your way seems to have them treating Sakura as if she is of absolutely zero importance except when they come crawling to her with wounds to heal, so....
Well, I can't see how Sakura is going to be strongly involved in any of the rest of it, given that it's set in Extra's world....Quote:
Well, if it makes you feel better, I can tell you in all honesty that that is not the case in this particular story.
Well, at it's core it's following the 'Ilya Route' for FSN, so... yeah.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike1984
In a more generalized meeting, yes, Sakura will be there and contributing overall in terms of ideas. (At least for my part, Grail Works is supposed to be collaborative storyline after all). But not in this very focused meeting with a single specific question.Quote:
Perhaps.
However, your way seems to have them treating Sakura as if she is of absolutely zero importance except when they come crawling to her with wounds to heal, so....
Well, I can't see how Sakura is going to be strongly involved in any of the rest of it, given that it's set in Extra's world....
And yes, Sakura isn't going to play a big role in this particular storyline. But that's not the same as (in your words) 'looking for excuses' not to include her.
Which makes Sakura "unimportant" how, exactly...?Quote:
Originally Posted by pureauthor
You don't seem to bother to even need to "look", you seem to have a ready-made one at hand....Quote:
And yes, Sakura isn't going to play a big role in this particular storyline. But that's not the same as (in your words) 'looking for excuses' not to include her.
Anyway, whatever. Our opinions on this clearly differ, and you're not going to suddenly magically include her (and nor, indeed, would it make sense to give her a significant role in the fic overall), so there's no point in me continuing to argue this.
It's a long story that will have several arcs. Sakura is not really included in this one, but she will be in future ones. It's not that he's attempting to exclude a member, but he's just keeping it simple. I mean, there are plenty of stories where a character doesn't come in until several chapters in. The author wasn't trying to be mean to that character, they just didn't have a proper place for them yet. I think you're just seeing too deeply into this, Mike. You see it as Sakura being ignored again, while I see it as simple not including her as a pointless cameo in this arc.
Well, I understand that Sakura isn't going to play a big role in this particular story, but they didn't even bother to acknowledge that she existed.