That's not a fact.
Printable View
That's not a fact.
You mean stuff like "Caren is Kotomines daughter"?
You mean implications? :/Quote:
Originally Posted by lantzblades
If it's going to be connected with the forum anyway (like a button on the top of the ribbon like the Forums and Blogs are) then we can leave all the speculation for the forum, since that's one of the primary functions of a forum anyhow.
http://ourchangingclimate.files.word...ed-1.jpg?w=450
*sigh* nevermind.
do what you will DP.
i'm out.
They would be if people started bashing her in them, yes....Quote:
Originally Posted by Neir
As long as it sticks to actual facts, it wouldn't be a problem. And, no "AM had no effect on Sakura" is not a "fact"....
...
Yeah, now given this, I don't think it is a good idea at all.
Mhmm, I can actually see this going quite troll-free if wiki vandalism will have forum punishments as consequences.
I mean flaming in blogs and stuff also falls under them, right?
>Implying powerlevels aren't factsQuote:
Originally Posted by Kratosirving
Who are you quoting?
I3uster, I like you.
Anyway, if this is gonna cause strife, never mind. I vote against it (can't change my fucking vote).
Anything is going to cause strife sooner or later, it's just a question of how it's handled.
Unless someone tries to blatantly troll this effort, it might finally become the ever distant utopia, a correct TM wiki with sourced information.
You know, I've heard about Mil's wiki, but today is the first time I actually found it. I always assumed it was still in progress, but apparently, it launched last November. I think, if he's alright with it, his content would be good material on such a thing. Overall, I thought a BL wiki a great idea, with up to date content.
Then I read Mike's comments and had second thoughts strong enough to make me want to change my vote to a resounding "NO." At the very least, we need an option to change our votes on polls.
I've no small amount of experience on Wikipedia, so if, as seems likely, this becomes a reality, I expect I'll be spending most of my time watching the trouble pages.
What, me stating something that I don't consider to be a "fact" that actually isn't a fact is a problem?Quote:
Originally Posted by RacingeR
Seriously, what do you think would happen if people start putting things like "Sakura is entirely responsible for everything that happens in HF" on the wiki? You don't need an explicit statement from me to work that out. Hell, even if I wasn't here, it would still happen....
It's quite possible to have a perfectly civil edit-war, though. Or, at least, just as civil as the arguments we have now....Quote:
Originally Posted by I3uster
OK, what?Quote:
Originally Posted by Black Sword
What is wrong with me wanting the wiki to actually be accurate and not contain character-bashing...?
Okay, honestly, now that I actually thought about it this might not be such a good idea after all. Edit wars are hardly ever civil, and it just seems like it's asking for a lot of trouble.
Shame I can't go back and change my vote. :p
If Mil would be willing to transfer his work over to this wiki, and scrap his own, it might make the new, centralized BL wiki a success.
I can see why the inconsistencies of the Type-moon wiki would cause concern, but in my opinion the TM wiki has been getting better...
I voted no to help out all the foolish people now seeing the error of their ways. Unfortunately I am only one sapient being.
So counting the 3 who want to switch their votes, the current situation is
Yes: 11
No: 9
I think we should make the Wiki just... not cover characters. Make it more about the objective stuff, like mechanics and plot and Servant stats. Also, it could be a nice repository for translated material that helps out in random debates.
What Five said would definitely be nice.