A cutting attack of that rank would obviously work. I'm just questioning blunt and energy attacks. If the bit about Bellerophon dropping Saber with 90% of it's power stopped is true then there should be no issue.
Printable View
Imagine thinking Cu Alter is on the same level as Lion King after seeing her Light of Judgement kek
https://lparchive.org/Fatestay-night/Update%20374/Quote:
They're both alive.Rider must've used up her magical energy as she's still on the ground.
But Sabershe's deeply wounded, but she still has some power left.
"!"
We barely had the edge in the confrontation of the Noble Phantasms.
Bellerophon had ninety percent of its light offset by Saber's holy sword.
Extella Karna vs Knights of the round?
I mean, individually its either Karna or a close battle, but the whole group? You've got one that could tank what Karna can dish out, one that at the very least approaches his skill level, two to three that can beam through his defenses, and one that sometimes kills with his eyes as well...
Individually of the known knights (Lancelot, Gawain, Mordred, Tristan, Bedivere), none can fight him without getting creamed except Gawain with Sun buff
I don't count Galahad or Agravainn cause god knows wtf can they do
1 vs the entire group however, Karna would get creamed
So the consensus is that Sun-buffed Gawain is so much stronger than Scáthach? What if we removed all NPs from the equation - no Galatine, no Gáe Bolg Alternative, no Gate of Skye?
You're taking away more from Scathach
Unless Primal Runes are super sugoi, but I'm not knowledgeable enough to comment about that
They're at least on Medea Spell Tier, they're super good.
But are there haha debuff/paralysis for x hours/haha I WIN spells in there??
She can literally use them to summon Servants without needing a grail IIRC
But can she do that before Gawain Falcon Punches her guts out?
Medea inside her temple could literally freeze space (however that works) to hold Archer in place.
I presume Scathach would at least have something that could slow Gawain enough for her to use more magic. Plus, her physical parameters are pretty close to peak Servant power, she should be able to tank or at least mitigate some damage.
But wouldn't that mean that Scathach would probably win with and without NP's?
The answer is probably yes. Or at least I give the win more often than not on the Primal Rune using Godslayer who can summon Servants as well as use fun spear techniques.
The main issue with Scathach vs are that (as far as I'm aware) she still has quite some unrevealed tricks, and has a lot of hype. But given that she jobbed at times she's seen as less impressive. (But Karna and Gil also job all the time so meh) Killing gods as a feat is generally impressive (but nasuverse seem to get downplayed in story, so maybe not as impressive) Primal Runes are ??? but probably very impressive considering what we have seen. Being a teacher of many heroes is a feat in of itself, imo, and maybe theres something else in one of her interludes but I'm very unsure about that at this point, since I cant find the interlude anymore
Tldr, scathach has secrets and hype feats, but in story she jobs, take that how you'd like to.
- - - Updated - - -
Rant away kids
Gawain has double her bases even before the x3, he's blasting her to kingdom come when he lands a hit. Also he has far better MR than Emiya, so he'd be able to resist her magic to an extent.
Shouldn't that be "if" he lands a hit? Isn't she supposed to be a weaponsmaster even above most Servants?
something2 vague as fuck immortality
extella link story and material book, save us
Most other jobbers actually do impressive things before they job i.e Gil, Karna, Ozy, Cu
Scathach doesn't even do those things, she just straight up job
Cu does seem to be able to put up a spell (just some spell, not even his NP or anything) to block a great noble phantasm, and considering she only taught him one of the sets she knows, she'd be above him in that, at the very least.
pls gaem give us some actual feats when Aife/Scaster/whoeverthefucksheis comes out
Just because the student can do something doesn't mean the teacher can also do said thing or is better at said thing
I.e, Cu and Achilles