Search:

And absolutely not serious. Heinous joke is heinous.

It does not matter what reality. It does not matter the medium. Shirou's sword is magical.

Because he is Shirou Kotomine in Archer's clothes? There's any way to be more GAR than that?

^^Say that to a medieval girl who claimed to hear the voice of God and went to war for that...
But, well, I guess I cannot really rule out the possibility of it being well worked. It still bugs the...

My issue is not with the coherence within the novel. That I do believe it haves. My complaints are about the accuracy to the historical character. Different from Arthur or Medea, there are historical...

Indeed. Her last words. The ones she said while she was being burned by people she knew where bought to kill her. I don't see why she would think her role had ended as much as she would believe the...

Her NP has the incantation "Oh, God, to you I lend this body". I guess it did not.

You see, that would be a valid interpretation if you didn't take what she said in the trial into account. She wore masculine clothing in large part because she did not believe herself as really being...

Even Arturia still kept the core of the character that was Arthur, as well as keeping his conviction and beliefs. It was a woman? Yes. But that woman held the same values as the mythological King...

The thing is: Jeanne refused to dress as a woman except if they let her take the Sacraments if she did it. And even then, she told them that she would take them off as soon as she could've. That was...

I think I've read somewhere that Jeanne goes to school. I probably misread it because it doesn't make any sense, you see.
Jeanne in a miniskirt? Really? That's ruining one of the most important...

So, basically, she, as a Servant, choose to use clothes that left her pretty much defenseless against attacks? But, well, there's Siegfried...
TBH, I normally wouldn't mind the design of the...

Except that the Round Table Knight designs are FAR from accurate. There was no plate armor in the sixth century, nor steel weaponry. Only Rome had the money needed to cover the costs of arming whole...

That makes sense. But sacrificing a Master like that is quite... hasty of them. They have backups, I suppose, but still.

There was no mention to Avicebron in the post I read as far as I remember. But, still, that pretty much joss that line of thought. And, well, considering Shakespeare wasn't even a Magus to begin...

Oh, my bad. My english grammar is far from perfect, I suppose. I meant that we have seen Casters stealing Command Seals before. There's the whole "He's a Magus so he can be a Master" deal. But, then...

It's not like we even saw a Caster stealing Command Seals and all...
To be fair, I am not very confortable with the idea of a Master copying a NP. It seems like just too much to me.

Wasn't one of Shakespeare's NPs the ability to change his form? Also, he has that Skill that lets him change the outcome and all... That could've been him.

Wow. That was very anticlimatic... And not very creative too.

That still would leave the problem of exactly how belief works... but nevermind that. I'm probably putting more tought into that than Nasu himself did.
P.S: If a Satsuki route is possible, then it's...

I like the second choice. Seems more like it. But the possibility of a Dresden Caster would sure be interesting.
P.S: Nobody cares about DDD, you know...

Well, Extra is written by Nasu and due to the Second Magic, it ties in with the continuity. I don't see any reason not to bring it up. Or am I missing some unwritten rule?

But the point is that nowadays you can prove a Medusa isn't real, thus it would cancel it. However, if we assume that because once it was assumed that it was absolutely real, then it would be...

I wouldn't say there are many Thrones, but rather that the Throne belongs outside Time and Space. Something like a Core function at the center of reality. A, say, compendium of information from all...

You do realize many people actually believe that the Necronomicon is real, right? It goes to the point where there are magical treatises about it. But, well, the validity of such treatises is...