Questions, questions and more questions (READ THE OP FOR ANSWERS)

[Lily Emilio]

Would it be alright to ask what they are? : O

Most of it is not really different from what we're doing here, but the main issue for me is the whole counterforce of Alaya doing flagging. We actually don't know who or what doing the pruning of timelines. Alaya doesn't have solar system influence. The issue with ESP explanation to me, is about the law of physics stuff. Also lack of mentioning how ESPers connected to Alaya.

- - - Updated - - -

So are Types just the biggest baddest lifeforms on their respective planet or actual avatars of their planet's will made specifically by their planet's will? Reading Notes gave me the impression it was the former, but I've heard the latter before too.

To me it's the former. Then those guys are selected by their home planet as the avatar.

- - - Updated - - -

good points
I wonder if the extella series will end with humans ascending the throne of the prime ones on the moon cell too in after a giant moon sengoku period.

I just hope after watching Avengers Infinity War, Nasu won't throw FateThanos in there and then it is revealed that Moon Cell and Velber thing is just info gathering devices to ensure the expansion of FateThanos's race universe of awareness beyond the galaxies.

- - - Updated - - -

Humanity universe of awareness, even if by some coincidence and extraneous situation, managed by some method incorporating / assimilating the gods, the aliens, and the bunch of other things and continue strong and sturdy as Human Order.

Humanity sugoi ne

I read a theory that the ancient alien race who made Moon Cell and Velber saw the potential planets that might become big for a solar system so it installed observation devices since the beginning, to gather information and control the parallel world system to their will. Now I'm actually very interested in those aliens lol.

Also do we even know what would really qualify as type earth

We don't have one so...

[castor212]

Alien civilization A, southern army : lets make an impartial observation device

Alien civilization A, northern army : lets make observation device that EATS THEM ALL YEAHHH

Civil War

[Shiki]

Does alaya has a personification?

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Yeah, he wears red, is kind of a busybody, flirts with bridge bunnies, and doesn't get along with Cu Chulainn.

[Shiki]

so emiya is a personification of alaya? i thought he is just a counter guardian only.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Alaya is mankind's prayer for survival. The thing that enacts that survival is the Counter Force. Guardians are the closest thing you've got to a "personification" of that abstraction.

[Shiki]

hmm i see, so all the counter force or guardians are the alaya? therefore it refers to several who embodies that will rather than a single individual?

[Lily Emilio]

Alien civilization A, southern army : lets make an impartial observation device

Alien civilization A, northern army : lets make observation device that EATS THEM ALL YEAHHH

Civil War

Perhaps one side believes that by expanding knowledge (awareness) about the universe and other races, they will expand their universe of awareness not just beyond their solar system but also to the entire universe, making them the prime race in the universe as pruning and QTLs system will now only cater to their race.

But the other side believes that the other races are too dangerous and must be absorbed before they figure out the mechanic, thus ensure them as the only race in the universe and the system will now only cater to them.

[castor212]

Velber is Reaper

[You]

So are Types just the biggest baddest lifeforms on their respective planet or actual avatars of their planet's will made specifically by their planet's will? Reading Notes gave me the impression it was the former, but I've heard the latter before too.

it's both

[onepieceuc1]

I read that Coral of the Moon takes place in a world where Tsukihime events didn't happen, can someone explain to me what would be the difference if it did?
Thanks as always !

[You]

I read that Coral of the Moon takes place in a world where Tsukihime events didn't happen, can someone explain to me what would be the difference if it did?
Thanks as always !

who knows. You got to ask what events of tsukihime.

Q: The concept of Tsuki no Sango is the "degenerated what if scenario" of Tsukihime 3000, but is Tsuki no Sango a potential future of Tsukihime universe?

A: Tsuki no Sango is a world where the event of Tsukihime did not occur. Different from EXTRA's "what if" scenario, the one of Tsuki no Sango is "a degenerated world where magecraft yet lingers". Tsuki no Sango has a Land of Steel type of world. (Note: I think Nasu is saying Tsuki no Sango and Land of Steel are spiritually similar, but the phrasing can be interpreted in such a way that they are in the same universe. I am not sure, lol.)

[Leftovers]

No Tsukihime presumably means no Aylesbury meaning no global mana drain meaning magecraft still exists in the future but the world is still fucked.

- - - Updated - - -

geh

[Arashi_Leonhart]

No Tsukihime presumably means no Aylesbury

I dunno, no Tsukihime but Extra still happens

[Leftovers]

No Tsukihime because Aylesbury happens early and no Aylesbury because Tsukihime doesn't happen, where's the problem?

- - - Updated - - -

Wait I see the problem, Tsukihime not happening doesn't affect Aylesbury's completion but its disruption.

- - - Updated - - -

Though I'm not sure if Terminator Arcueid or Satsujinki would be more useful when crashing the party.

[pinetree]

Do we know what Geronimo's little robot-familiar-thing is? None of his skills mention it.

[asterism42]

It's related to his magecraft, I think. A familiar. I have the impression it's some sort of spirit, but idk where I got it from.

[pinetree]

His magecraft does involve talking to fairies and borrowing their power by means of contract, but it doesn't mention the robot so I don't think it is one.

I wonder if All the Statesman talks about it.

[Iceblade44]

Pretty sure that thing is the guardian spirit that's his skill, tho why it's a floating metal ball and not a coyote I have no idea.

[pinetree]

Pretty sure that thing is the guardian spirit that's his skill, tho why it's a floating metal ball and not a coyote I have no idea.

Maybe the artist just saw Helena and thought it was cooler than a dog?

I think it being a fairy for his Shamanism is more likely than it being his Coyote though.