What if _________ was _________'s servant?

[zikari8]

I wonder if Kayneth has the Brynhildr's Beloved trait.

[forumghost]

Doubt it, the only person that loves Kayneth is Kayneth.

[34]

What if Prelati was Ryuunosuke's Servant?

[hayate]

What if Prelati was Ryuunosuke's Servant?

Don't even wish for it.

The Fourth Holy Grail War will be all sorts of messed up if it happened.

He'll just play mind games on every Servant and Master that he will encounter.

Emphasis on his own Master, no less.

And with that said, let's get this one going...

Gaen Izuko (Monogatari) as Emiya Kiritsugu's Servant.

[SleepMode]

What if Kayneth summons Darius III for the 4th HGW?

[Renko]

What if Kayneth summons Darius III for the 4th HGW?

Darius III vs Iskandar rematch battle will happen.

[34]

What if Kayneth summons Darius III for the 4th HGW?

So, Kariya summons Lancer Lance-a-lot?
Well, just replace Saber vs Deermuid fights with Darius vs Iskandar

[AvengerEmiya]

What if David, Benkei, George, and Kintoki took Atalanta, Karna, Achilles, and Spartacus's place in the Red Faction?

[34]

What if David, Benkei, George, and Kintoki took Atalanta, Karna, Achilles, and Spartacus's place in the Red Faction?

George will teach Shirou how to be a proper saint.

[Draconic]

David goes after former Nazi Darnic PlagiarismPrestone Yggdmillenia, then miraculously defeats two stronger servants before being killed himself showing Sieg the true meaning of kingship: Protecting one's people.

And then Sieg will spend another half-hour/ten pages asking himself what his purpose in life is, as well as trying to figure out why he didn't die, and why David died for him.

Which for the record is: David himself doesn't even know why he sacrificed himself for this kid, so… yeah. uh… quick! They're on to us! Put

Astolfo

the distraction

in here, quick!

[forumghost]

What if David, Benkei, George, and Kintoki took Atalanta, Karna, Achilles, and Spartacus's place in the Red Faction?

At least one of them probably kills themselves to give Sieg another power-up

[zikari8]

Kintoki doesn't get himself taken out immediately. As a righteous hero of all children, he can't stop himself from helping out the poor little baby homunculus.

He has the inevitable lightning Berserker fight with Fran but ends up sacrificing himself to protect Sieg.

[34]

What if Alkeides was Ilya's Servant?

[Nobody]

What if Alkeides was Ilya's Servant?

He wipes out everyone then gets wiped out by Gilgamesh.

[RoydGolden]

What if Kayneth summoned Astolfo (Lancer Class) instead of Diarmuid? Would he still get NTRed?

[zikari8]

What if Kayneth summoned Astolfo (Lancer Class) instead of Diarmuid? Would he still get NTRed?

Nah, Sola-Ui'd be NTR'd.

[Omida]

What would change if Celenike summoned Medb instead of Astolfo?

I mean, I don't expect Medb change how fucked Black Faction is.

For the changes, I am pretty sure that Sieg storyline would be axed, because I don't see her helping him, so he probably feeds Avicebron's NP.

Which means Siegfried's suicide is averted (on the other hand, he is very likely to be target of Medb's affections). Chiron and Vlad are probably also on Medb's rape list in Black Faction, which may strain Black's cohesiveness more than events of canon.

On the other hand, she may be directed onto Red Team with their Karna, Achilles and Spartracus (and after reveal, maybe Shirou, which means Semiramis vs Medb catfight :V).

[RoydGolden]

What would change if Celenike summoned Medb instead of Astolfo?

I mean, I don't expect Medb change how fucked Black Faction is.

For the changes, I am pretty sure that Sieg storyline would be axed, because I don't see her helping him, so he probably feeds Avicebron's NP.

Which means Siegfried's suicide is averted (on the other hand, he is very likely to be target of Medb's affections). Chiron and Vlad are probably also on Medb's rape list in Black Faction, which may strain Black's cohesiveness more than events of canon.

On the other hand, she may be directed onto Red Team with their Karna, Achilles and Spartracus (and after reveal, maybe Shirou, which means Semiramis vs Medb catfight :V).

The rapist meets the crazy psycho-sexual sadist. I think that's just about the

best

worst

Master-Servant pairing since Uryuu and Gilles...

Speaking of teams that would match personality-wise but really shouldn't happen, what if Celenike summoned Elizabeth Bathory?

[the god of world-0]

What would change if Celenike summoned Medb instead of Astolfo?

I mean, I don't expect Medb change how fucked Black Faction is.

For the changes, I am pretty sure that Sieg storyline would be axed, because I don't see her helping him, so he probably feeds Avicebron's NP.

Which means Siegfried's suicide is averted (on the other hand, he is very likely to be target of Medb's affections). Chiron and Vlad are probably also on Medb's rape list in Black Faction, which may strain Black's cohesiveness more than events of canon.

On the other hand, she may be directed onto Red Team with their Karna, Achilles and Spartracus (and after reveal, maybe Shirou, which means Semiramis vs Medb catfight :V).

Well, she could save sieg, just to rape him afterwards. He has a innocent look that she might wanted to corrupt

[Omida]

Speaking of teams that would match personality-wise but really shouldn't happen, what if Celenike summoned Elizabeth Bathory?

I guess Romania is close enough that Black Team would have two Servants with homefield advantage. Also, from the context you mean Carmilla?

Well, Fiore might want to keep Chiron with her at all times.