Originally Posted by
eddyak
It's because he has amazing moments, interspersed with really fucking dumb moments.
Great idea: A well-thought out HGW with original characters and few throwbacks to the original.
Terrible idea: Double the number of participants, necessitating 7+7+7+7 characters as central characters, plus whatever other characters are needed for an actual story.
Great idea: Exploring the idea of a newborn "human" in the midst of a bunch of long-dead legends who lived their lives to the fullest.
Terrible idea: lul hes now ultraman siegfried and also frankenstein and also rly super powerful hisself and also jannu want his dicc and astolfo wanna astolfo his astolfo and and and then he TURNS INTO A DRAGON WHOA why does this read like something he and hs mates came up with while drunk and high and also overdosing on something
Great idea: Their frankly amazing death scenes, baring their hearts and motivations.
Terrible idea: The twisted convoluted bullshit he had to come up with to push them into those situations.