TM Fanfics Index: Recommendations & Discussion. Updates never

[Kyte]

Link to wildbow being a shithead?

I tend to assume people are decent unless I've got evidence to the contrary.

IRC, mostly. I don't save the logs. Like i said, Fran can rant at length.

[DezoPenguin]

All of which can perfectly well be explained by, you know, bad writing.

Eh, I like to think the best of people. And if something makes me laugh and does't horrifies me, I classify it as comedy. Even if the author doesn't think it is. So, in this case, I classify it as (accidental) comedy.

So, Poe's Law, then?

[Ergast]

Basically. Given, writting accidental comedy is bad writting, but I'm not going to give a -1 to something that I actually enjoyed reading. And I definitely not going to take seriously a HPxFSN crossover until proven otherwise. And in this case, it wasn't.

[Techlet]

Sure, this Harry was "edgier" than normal, but again, he grew (at least the last two-three years) in an edgier verse.

I really don't see how the Nasuverse is any edgier than HP.

[Ergast]

My mistake. I forgot to put the quotes. Given, though, the magi in the Nasuverse are used to walk with death, while the wizards aren't, but I intended to be sarcastic in this case. So I should have written this:

Sure, this Harry was "edgier" than normal, but again, he grew (at least the last two-three years) in an "edgier" verse.

[Vagrant]

Wait, have I not already given a +1 to Hearts of the Suffering? I thought I'd done that after my first read of it. Whoops.

+1 then.

[Bloble]

If anything, the universe with life imprisonment with no second chances & torture as automatic punishment for murder fits more easily the bill.

I counter with garden gnomes. Their existence is so anti-edge that they tip the balance the other way.

[DezoPenguin]

I counter with garden gnomes. Their existence is so anti-edge that they tip the balance the other way.

I cheat, because Crosswinds of Fate made this comparison and I just read it yesterday, but I counter your garden gnomes with Magical Ruby.

[ItsaRandomUsername]

Ruby is a fate worse than death, if you're Rin.

[Vagrant]

Neco Arc and co.

[Bloble]

Canon only pls. Otherwise I'm calling in the Crumple-Horned Snorkack.

[Kirby]

babbity wabbity and the cackling stump

[Vagrant]

Canon only pls. Otherwise I'm calling in the Crumple-Horned Snorkack.

>implying that the Neco-Arc species isn't canon in some splinter of the Nasuverse

[Erlkonig]

>implying there's a canon in the first place given Zelretch's kaleidoscope

[Vagrant]

That just means it's all canon.

[Kyte]

FSN is Neco-Shirou's fever dream.

[Sinon]

^New headcanon.

[Kyte]

He passed out in the kitchen because Ahnenerbe had a major rush hour and Neco-Shinji ditched on him.

[meevanhelot]

>implying there's a canon in the first place given Zelretch's kaleidoscope

That just means it's all canon.

Infinite worlds != Infinite possibilities.

Stuff can totally still be impossible and not happen in any universe.

Like Prisma Illya. Fuck /a/.

Neco Arc is canon though.

[meevanhelot]

Is it really an argument? There aren't infinite possibilities in actual many worlds theory. Only in pop culture. From a purely logical standpoint the idea of infinite possibilities being a result of infinite parallel universe doesn't make sense. So unless a setting explicitly says there are infinite possibilities that result, there shouldn't be any reason for people to think there is.