Heaven's Feel Manga Thread

[Nobody]

Seems like volume 4 releases on June 2

https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/4041056470/

Can't wait.

[TheSeaDragon]

nice Rider cover.

now seriously. Thats a nice lookin cover

[Rokudaime]

Any chance we can post copies of the links to the various translated chapters on the first page, like what was done for the first few chapters (and up until chapter 7 in the translation thread)? I've downloaded and read up until chapter 9, and I haven't actively visited this site for ages, so I'm unsure where we are, and I'd have to sift through tons of pages to try and find the links to the various chapters that have been translated since the last time I visited...

[fumei]

The chapters are hosted up to date on bato.to (up to chapter 13, as it was the last to be typeset).

[Rokudaime]

The chapters are hosted up to date on bato.to (up to chapter 13, as it was the last to be typeset).

OK, thanks.

[Tepanyakigo]

Question... is this manga any good? I've read the first FSN manga and it got me traumatised with Type-Moon manga adapatation....

The only awesome manga of TypeMoon I've ever read is only Tsukihime. They did great job with the manga for it.
Melty Blood was okay but not so good

[EDreamer]

It's been a LONG time since the first FSN manga, and Type-Moon has come to hire better writers and artists for their manga adaptations. So yes, this manga is definitely worth a read if you're a fan of the Heaven's Feel route, since it's not only faithful to the original but expands it in interesting ways. (And the art is superb, especially for Sakura.)

[Altima of the Gates]

I was kinda worried that the manga would have been a mess because it's being done by Task Ohna, a person who does mostly comedic Fate parody material(with his circle A/O Laboratory) comedic Fate material that tries to make the Matou household like some odd Addam's Family like atmosphere. Though Prisma came from a guy who does comedic Fate parodies too, so there you go.

But it has surprised me for the most part as of now to handle a serious route like this. The Zouken Gundam kind of shows his affection for the old cart though, lol.

[Kotonoha]

If anything you should have been reassured that a longtime TM collaborator who obviously loves HF was covering it rather than some rando.

[Altima of the Gates]

Well that did help. But then again, I would be wary even if Himura did it, and he's a known Sakura guy. Some Sakurabros are weird.

I weighed it all and things came about equal in terms of who I would want to do a HF adaptation.

Pluses

Likes Sakura.
Likes HF.
Big Fate and TM fan in general.


Minuses

Only ero doujins he made were Shinji/Sakura. Nothing else. I would excuse it if there were other pairings since we all have our tastes, but nope. So minus.
Only does comedic parodies. I like comedy, but if it gets too meme worthy, it's a minus for me, it's why I like Fue's style of comedy rather than Carnival Phantasm.

We can't always have lightning strike twice with good Fate stuff from comedic doujin writers like Prisma did, so I was pleasantly surprised with what I got. But it's only been the first few days of the route, so I'll pass judgement when it ends.

[Kotonoha]

Only ero doujins he made were Shinji/Sakura. Nothing else. I would excuse it if there were other pairings since we all have our tastes, but nope. So minus.

Well it wasn't "doujins" so much as a one-time 4-page contribution to a group doujin anthology with a theme of "artists who have never done porn, doing porn" so I wouldn't really represent him as this fervent Shinji/Sakura shipper

hell I'd argue it was a fairly in-character portrayal of how it might have gone down in canon as opposed to some of the really out-there fetish stuff people usually do with that pairing (and it also wasn't comedy for once! so there's that too)

Well that did help. But then again, I would be wary even if Himura did it, and he's a known Sakura guy. Some Sakurabros are weird.

Himura has good art and all but I would never trust him with official Fate stuff after he tweeted something like "I didn't watch UBW but now that the PROLOGUE is over we can get to the REAL Fate/stay night where Sakura is saved" (then someone told him Sakura seemed dead-eyed in the epilogue and he was like "good"). Stick to putting phones on boobs dude

[Altima of the Gates]

Well yeah, as I said, some Sakurabros are weird, I did not say that lightly. Sorry for the late reply, been busy.

[mewarmo990]

Himura has good art and all but I would never trust him with official Fate stuff after he tweeted something like "I didn't watch UBW but now that the PROLOGUE is over we can get to the REAL Fate/stay night where Sakura is saved" (then someone told him Sakura seemed dead-eyed in the epilogue and he was like "good"). Stick to putting phones on boobs dude

それが悪いのか

[Broke]

Who's Himura?

[Strange_One]

Artist. Drew Archerkos and Sakuras back in the day.

Draws Sword Art Online Progressive Manga. Most recently draws vignettes of girls with huge cup sizes on twitter which apparently is popular enough make doujin and anime shorts of.

[Broke]

Oh, Himura Kiseki.

I remember him from his Illya art.

Spoiler:

[Strange_One]

I miss Archerko ;_;

[Tepanyakigo]

I miss Archerko ;_;

She's dead... DEAD DEAD... because we have Kuro now... but yeah... Sword Dancers was a good doujin indeed.

I'm a bit curious... I am always torn apart whenever TypeMoon manga adaptation comes out... The FSN manga was BAD even worse than DEEN UBW movie IMHO... Melty Blood was fun but average at best... Tsukihime was splendid... so the average is still being average...

Is there any possibility that this adaptation is going to be a huge mess of trainwreck?

[Strange_One]

As a cult recruiter preached to me I declare - DO NOT ACCEPT


And it's been pretty damn good so far. FSN and Zero weren't that good looking from the start. For HF to go the same way that'd be a helluva nosedive.

[Yggdrasil]

Raws of chapters 26-27-28 out
http://raw.senmanga.com/Fate-Stay-Ni...39;s-Feel/26/1