Rulings:
1) I should not have to make 'rulings' on this like some sort of judge in court. You're all children.
2) It's not a copy.
3) Who cares, creating a true magic and creating a magecraft aren't so distinct as to need separate threads.
4) They're both bad, memeposting threads either because this isn't a topic actually interesting enough in itself, or because no-one's managed to set a good example for the threads to want to imitate. Or both.
5) I'm merging them in Fanfics. Per usual forum policy, whichever of you ends up as OP does not get any special powers, primacy, or even respect in-thread. You simply have the chance to make it a better place by providing a functional first post.