Create-A-Servant 2

[Kabalisto Koga]

I did a shitty sheet of him. Probably Koga meant that

Not really... It's nice and at least it's not a degenerate genderbent

King of Padoru i found Ghatotkacha quite good because i like such honorfull Deep Warrior charackters like i ve also made Goliath as one ,but i would give him perhaps more Astras and why has he actually Archer qualfications again ?I will make later also some Indian Servants like some of the Pandavas and a certain Lady.

But at everyone which was my best Servant until now ??

[the god of world-0]

Hermes, have thou forsaken me?

[King of Padoru]

why has he actually Archer qualfications again ?

Throws stuff. By the way, he faced Karna without any astra

[Shiki-pon]

But at everyone which was my best Servant until now ??

Not to sound too harsh, but as has been stated before, they're all kinda terrible in their own way.
Still, I'd say the best is "Gladios", not just in comparison but overall. Stats are reasonable, Skills actually have something to do with the myth, and the gladiators don't have laser cannons or some such nonsense. Your only misstep with the sheet was in the Noble Phantasm department, where you decided to give them the ability to summon Spartacus and other famous gladiators and then gave them all Tsubame Gaeshi (kinda loses the uniqueness if some random literally no-name gladiator can pull it off - then again, that description also fits Kojiro to some extent).
Still, you might want to aim for something more like that one in the future. Just tone down the Noble Phantasms and everything will be fine. It's ok for Servants to be specialized (as opposed to mastering literally everything you can think of).
Anyways, apologies for the apparent harshness (at least I answered).

[MehKitteh]

Throws stuff. By the way, he faced Karna without any astra

Still loses though.

[King of Padoru]

Only because Duryodhana was scared and ordered Karna to use Vasavi Shakti

[Spartacus]

I hate TM for making Karna never shot VS, effectively cheapening the death of Gathotkach.

[Kabalisto Koga]

Not to sound too harsh, but as has been stated before, they're all kinda terrible in their own way.
Still, I'd say the best is "Gladios", not just in comparison but overall. Stats are reasonable, Skills actually have something to do with the myth, and the gladiators don't have laser cannons or some such nonsense. Your only misstep with the sheet was in the Noble Phantasm department, where you decided to give them the ability to summon Spartacus and other famous gladiators and then gave them all Tsubame Gaeshi (kinda loses the uniqueness if some random literally no-name gladiator can pull it off - then again, that description also fits Kojiro to some extent).
Still, you might want to aim for something more like that one in the future. Just tone down the Noble Phantasms and everything will be fine. It's ok for Servants to be specialized (as opposed to mastering literally everything you can think of).
Anyways, apologies for the apparent harshness (at least I answered).

Thank you Shiki-pon ! I appreciate it very much that (atleast)you gave me your answer !

[Lambda-Nu]

Now I'm curious as to what you'd consider my best sheet. Personally, I'm more proud of my Vritra and Forty-Seven Ronin sheets more than my others. Robespierre and Bizet were humongous failures, on the other hand.

[RoydGolden]

Now I'm curious as to what you'd consider my best sheet. Personally, I'm more proud of my Vritra and Forty-Seven Ronin sheets more than my others. Robespierre and Bizet were humongous failures, on the other hand.

You don't have a compilation so I can't be bothered to look through all of them. But your Beast Vritra was a stand-out entry.

[Lambda-Nu]

Okay. Give me a moment and I'll compile a list.

[Lambda-Nu]

My list of Servants I've done. Green indicates my personal favorites and red indicates the ones I hate.

Saber
Saber - Masamune
Saber/Rider/Caster/Berserker - Uncle Sam
Saber - Yamato Takeru (V2.0)
Saber - Ou Yezi

Archer
Archer - Al Capone (V2.0)

Lancer
Lancer - Georges Bizet
Lancer/Shielder - Pheidipiddes

Rider
Rider - The White Rider
Rider - The Red Rider
Rider - The Ship of Theseus

Caster
Caster - Herodotus
Caster - Karl Marx
Caster - Khosrow I
Caster - Nameless Witch

Assassin
Assassin - Maximilien Robespierre
Assassin - Spanish Inquisition
Assassin - William Afton
Assassin - Ītzpāpālōtl (Lostbelt)

Berserker
Berserker - Elizabeth Bathory (Alter)
Berserker/Archer - La Serrana de la Vera
Berserker - Iskandar (Alter)
Berserker - Tamiya Iemon & Yotsuya Oiwa

Avenger
Avenger - Forty-Seven Ronin
Avenger - Mahatma Nuclear Gandhi (V2.0)
Avenger - Vlad III (Lostbelt)

Ruler
N/A

Saver
Saver - Zoroaster

Alter Ego
Alter Ego - Hachiko

Foreigner
Foreigner - Akhenaten

Beast
Beast - Vritra

[RoydGolden]

My list of Servants I've done. Green indicates my personal favorites and red indicates the ones I hate.

Saber/Rider/Caster/Berserker - Uncle Sam
Saber - Yamato Takeru

Lancer - Georges Bizet

Caster - Herodotus
Caster - Karl Marx

Assassin - Maximilien Robespierre

Avenger - Forty-Seven Ronin

Beast - Vritra

...Why do the links not actually lead to the sheets in question but just random unrelated threads? Is that a joke?

[Lambda-Nu]

Oh for the love of God! Why did that happen? I’ll have to go backlater and fix that. I’m a bit busy with real life stuff at the moment.

[EVA-Saiyajin]

Quick question, how does one make these Spoiler tabs open, of which many Servant profiles have? Clicking on them does nothing.

[Leftovers]

If you're browsing on the mobile forum skin, you can't. Try changing it by clicking on <<Full Site>> at the bottom.

[EVA-Saiyajin]

If you're browsing on the mobile forum skin, you can't. Try changing it by clicking on <<Full Site>> at the bottom.

Ah, thank you very much. That was a HUGE pain in the ass.

[gyrowins]

St Olga of Kiev: Ah, the edgiest saint of all. I like these kinds of sheets but i've seen a few Avengers of her, Ruler Alter however...

I haven't actually seen any other sheets of Avenger!Olga after FGO popularized Avengers. Do you have any I could look at for comparison?

[RoydGolden]

I haven't actually seen any other sheets of Avenger!Olga after FGO popularized Avengers. Do you have any I could look at for comparison?

Here's one.

[Kabalisto Koga]

Some thoughts on a few sheets recently

Uesugi Kenshin (Der Ritter edition): I've seen a few Kenshin's and the majority of them bring at least one thing unique. I've seen unique skills, talking swords, swords that sheet dragons instead of beams and God Modes. Now while this isn't bad by any stretch, there's nothing I haven't seen before. You could perhaps try changing the second NP into creating an 'Ideal Avatar forged by Kenshin's way of life' or whatever and turned it into a Stand because that's something I haven't actually seen before. Also an original skill would be quite beneficial to the sheet. You could look at mine or Spartacus's for inspiration or just merge some pre-existing ones together. Easy one is making a skill called 'God of War' and combining Divinity with one of the other skills yoiu currently have.

Rider of the Turbulent Times: Red Hare is good to see, the Divinity aspect you combined into it was quite good as well and added another good layer to it.

St Olga of Kiev: Ah, the edgiest saint of all. I like these kinds of sheets but i've seen a few Avengers of her, Ruler Alter however...

Balor: I too agree that the Mystic Eye of Death could have a full power release that functions as an NP, it would be better than 'just' a seal NP.

You havent reacted/ said anithing about my Gladios,Suhrawardi or Herodot(halfversion),Bird of Hermes ! ��