You think? Granted the serials are from 1912, but the character himself is from the Civil War. Might be enough to squeak in, but it'd be kinda funny anywhere but on Moon Cell. "I'm stronger in this low gravity environment - but we are on Earth so back to normal". Oops.Originally Posted by JetKinen
I've never read the book/saw the movie so there is that.
I'm going mostly of the publication date in the wikipedia.
Obviously he'd have a Reality Marble/some kind of ability that brings him and the opponent to a "Mars"-like environment.
Well , someone posted a Abdul Alhazred, who was first mentioned in 1939, and nobody complained. I think that if you said "he was real in the Nasuverse", it could work. After all, Chtulhu exist in canon, so why not ?
Last edited by Alexcoene; November 23rd, 2016 at 01:39 PM.
He is older than servants like Ned Kelly, Red Baron, Simo Hayha, and other modern servants though.
The time period he would be from is about 1800s-1860s, when Shaka Zulu, Queen Victoria, were running around, and just after the era of Napoleon.
Last edited by WhatShouldNotBe; November 23rd, 2016 at 01:41 PM.
None of those should be Servants either.
Fate/Grand Order Doujins That Don't Suck [Updated: 3/2]
Mata Hari says hi.
Yeah but his book is not from that time period was it.
Old Li Shuwen is a better example; he died, IIRC, in the 1930s.
on one hand, I'm not really sure how canon compliant it is under standard circumstances.
however, Nasu rules are subverted all the time, plus you could argue that "he was based on a real civil war soldier" and sneak him in. Besides, people make modern heroic servants in this thread all the time. (Whether they should or not is debatable, but they do.)
so really, it's up to you. If you want to, you could probably make it work in some capacity.
Call of Chtulu was not really antideluvian either yet here he is, right in Gilles's summoning chant for his demons.
Last edited by Alexcoene; November 23rd, 2016 at 02:16 PM.
Everyone barring Simo Hayha that was named there has been born prior to the 1900-1904 cut-off.
The Phantom of the Opera (French: Le Fantôme de l'Opéra) is a novel by French writer Gaston Leroux. It was first published as a serialisation in Le Gaulois from September 23, 1909, to January 8, 1910. It was published in volume form in late March 1910 by Pierre Lafitte.fuck the whatJohn Carter was the lead character in the first novel by Edgar Rice Burroughs, set on a fictionalized version of Mars known as Barsoom. Written between July and September 28, 1911, the novel was serialized as Under the Moons of Mars in the pulp magazine The All-Story from February to July 1912. It later appeared as a complete novel only after the success of Burroughs' Tarzan series. For its October 1917 hardcover publication by A.C. McClurg & Company, the novel was retitled A Princess of Mars.
- - - Updated - - -
but definitely not this
Last edited by You; November 23rd, 2016 at 02:26 PM.
Though abandoned, forgotten, and scorned as out-of-date dolls, they continue to carry out their mission, unchanged from the time they were designed.
Machines do not lose their worth when a newer model appears.
Their worth (life) ends when humans can no longer bear that purity.
Phantom of the Opera is a more recent book than you'd think, that's for sure. It sorta gives the impression of being about fifty years older than it actually is.
Oh yeah, forgot about him. Well that settles it in my opinion. Go ahead, Whatshouldnotbe.
Edit: Tough I really wonder what his class is going to be...
Last edited by Alexcoene; November 23rd, 2016 at 02:33 PM.
It's pretty obvious GO kind of did away with the pre-established rules in order to find more low-hanging fruit they could make Servants out of. Or maybe book Servants are just special.
I mean, Vlad gets infinitely stronger by calling on the powers of the book that was written three years before the cutoff date. Either way, it's not like we haven't had a bunch of WWI/II and in between Servants in here already.
Hence I said "Or some other kind of ability".
@ All these Telemachus sheets: I like the base idea as well, but for some reason I have this image of his bow NP being actually impossible for him to string "properly" and he just uses it some other way normally
Then after character development in a fic he strings the thing and "surpasses/equals his father" in the symbolic sense
Idk just a thought
@John Carter of Mars, something something he's a wraithlike existence inspired by a true story of someone actually going to another realm (Other Side or some elemental's RM or something) and summoned as "John Carter of Mars" something like Kojirou; bam, now you can bullshit it
and the wraith is born before 1900
so i guess you could do it with something along those lines but i wouldn't personally because i don't much like the idea itself
oh i should clean up and post a sheet i have here actually, nearly forgot this thread existed
When you read a post you made five years agoaccurate descriptions of Type-Moon media
Uh, can you use punctuation and not make a paragraph for each sentence in your posts, please ? Because I think that they will quickly become annoying to read if you keep them like that. And I think this topic of discussion is pretty much closed by now.
Last edited by Alexcoene; November 23rd, 2016 at 03:13 PM.
Well Phantom of the Opera's summoning is possible because the individual who the book was based on was born prior to the 1900 cut off it seems and the Phantom you summon is basically that individual that's been affected and attributed with the book's content. So John Carter of Mars could be made into a Servant by saying that the individual who the book was based on was born prior to the cut off, which seems to be actually true judging from some of the comments in this thread.
Posting Permissions
