Originally Posted by
Deathhappens
According to her profile:
"The countess of blood that became the model for the vampire Carmilla... or it should have been, but what was summoned as a Servant was her 14 year-old self from before committing any crimes. A sweet-type Servant who calls herself an idol. Noble, high-handed, cruel, merciless - she displays inhuman manners just like in legends. "
Now maybe this is the same thing written differently, but to me it seems to say that THIS Liz hasn't yet commited the atrocities assigned to her name, and in fact her character arc in Orleans was all about her rejecting that version of herself and vowing not to end up like that.
That doesn't mesh with the Elizabeth who did commit those crimes, accepted the blame and tried to atone for them in Extella. (And failed and backslid in her evil ways for a while, but that just made her story more interesting).