Well, I have to agree with that.Originally Posted by Erlkonig
Just "you'll get sucked in", I think.Though I wonder-- What did Keyne write? Erotical Black hole?
I don't troll the Shinji fanclub, I just don't like the fact that I'm not allowed to mention that he's a total asshole even though he quite patently is.
Mike, clothed sex or naked sex? It could be about any T-M girl or real life. What would you choose?
Because it is a fan club, not a discussion club.
But they're eulogising an attempted mass-murderer and repeated rapist....
In my case, EVERYTHING i write is nonsensical.
JAJAJA.Flip the skirt up and SLAM it in!
If we disallow fanclubs for murderers and rapists this section would be pretty much empty.
for example, sakura is a mass-murderer too. =p
but a serial killer is fine too.
If we look at it legally, it wasn't Sakura that did the killing.
That is, she could put forward an insanity plea.
OH NO DO NOT START THAT IN HERE!
But seriously, Kotomine also has a fanclub, and he isn't really that much of a nice person.
*prepares the Pizza RM*
I don't think she'd even need to do that, actually, at least not in this country. There was a case a year or so ago where someone killed their wife in their sleep (thinking she was a burglar or something), and they were ruled not guilty of murder (or even manslaughter) because they had not been in consciously aware of their actions. As for the two or three people she did kill consciously (depending on whether you consider killing Shinji to be a conscious act), two of them were self-defense. The only one who wasn't was Kotomine, really, and there she would indeed just plead insanity.
And a fictional one, too~
Shiki Tohno can rape people. Shirou can be a coward too. And Sakura can devour both Tohsaka and Shirou into the darkness. People gloss over things like that when they're setting up fanclubs.
That man should put forth an insanity plea. Any man who sees a strange woman in his house and kills her definitely needs to fix his priorities.
Double Post for Great Justice!
That's in your country, what about the laws of Japan? Do they allow insanity and self-defense? Is it really self-defense? What are the conditions?
Unless you're doing that to troll Mike, I'd point out that overall that's really trivial. Personally, I don't care what the law of a country says about someone's moral standing; a government isn't a god. Whether it's Japan or Taiwan, the idea of what constitutes proper self-defense and insanity should, though isn't necessarily, be global. We could probably make better progress on this topic by tackling that.
But let me tell you, Tohno-san. The penal code of Japan seems to have differences from the global perspective. There, you either can get a decade or death penalty. That's it. Let us suppose their views on defense and insanity is different.
Oh, well, if the topic is about what kind of sentence Sakura should get in Japanese Law, then, uh, carry on. I thought we were talking about morality and ethics, not legal systems. >.>
He didn't "see a strange woman in his house", he was dreaming that someone had attacked him, so he turned around in his sleep and strangled his wife/girlfriend.
Yeah, this. It is not remotely relevant what the law of Japan says on the matter (neither in terms of our decision or in terms of what will actually happen to her), all that is important is whether she is morally responsible.
And?
What relevance does the law have to someone who is far more powerful than anyone who will enforce it?
Well, I certainly wasn't talking about that. Plus, I agree entirely with you. The sentence she "should" get in Japan is the same as the sentence she should get in the rest of the world. And, for that matter, the sentence she would get in Japan is the same also, that being "not guilty by reason of Rider"....
And you think Magi are invulnerable to modern weaponry? Remember Kiritsugu. If a gun wouldn't kill her, then surely a missile. That is, if she resists arrest.
Nevertheless, "should" is not the same as "would".
Well, ignoring the fact that she's never going to get found out, I very much doubt that they would go to those lengths to arrest someone. The only way they would even consider such actions is if they knew that she was a magus, which would mean that she would have far worse things to worry about than the Japanese government trying to arrest her. And, even if they did, they'd have to do it with no warning, because whilst Sakura might not be able to tank a missile, Rider sure as hell could.
She probably wouldn't, but there's no way in hell either Rider or Shirou would allow her to be executed, or even sentenced to a prison spell.That is, if she resists arrest.
Yes, and given that the government has no way of finding out that she's responsible, no way of proving it and no way of enacting her sentence, what "would" happen is precisely nothing.Nevertheless, "should" is not the same as "would".
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
