TM Fanfics Index: Recommendations & Discussion. Updates never

[Leo Novum]

+1 to The Extraordinary Life of Matou Shinji. That stuff's good.

[Mattias]

+1 to The Extraordinary Life of Matou Shinji.

The Grail War as seen through Shiji-tinted glasses. Or at least the prologue. Including Shiji's thoughts on Archery (I'm definatly the captain), Zouken (99% supervillian), Tohsaka (So into me), magi (Constantly searching for some library) and many more.

[Kirby]

+0. I didn't find it that funny, and the jokes were basically exactly as you'd expect them to be. Maybe you'll like it, maybe you won't.

[Kyte]

+1 to
The Extraordinary Life of Matou Shinji



A nice snippet of what a theoretical autobiography by Shinji might read like. The humour is fresh, Shinji is Shinji doing Shinji things, and the whole thing has this casual sort of atmosphere that can only be imparted by a magnificent bastard downplaying everything not relevant to his greatness. The only flaw is that it ends far too quickly.

Link

[Kirby]

http://forums.nrvnqsr.com/showthread...%28One-Shot%29

[Christemo]

+1 to Before the Eye of God by Siriel.

Douglas Williams is a hardboiled detective in Portland, Maine and the primary investigator involved in a nasty pair of ritualistic murders committed with copper stakes. With nothing but his wit, his partner-in-being-hilarious-halfjerk cops Jon and the enigmatic Second Owner of the city, Leonard Conroy, who has a bad habit of hypnotizing Douglas to get information for his private investigations, our brave coffee critic tries to solve the crime of the murders that have clear links to the supernatural, the world Douglas is entirely unfamiliar with, which his pestering Magus "friend" is the supreme authority of in the area.

It's a detective fic of an entirely OC characters in a Nasu setting, with little to no actual magic. It's a perfect mix of humor and seriousness, and entirely compensates for the usually quantity-lacking humor in Siriel's other works. Douglas is, so far, one of those characters who despite being pretty simple in being your run-of-the-mill snarky detective is extremely compelling, and Conroy, despite less screentime is also quite interesting. The story, despite only having nine chapters so far and seeming to be on a small hiatus (Siriel pls continuerino), shows amazing promise. Definite reccomendation from here.

[SINIB]

+1 to before the eye of god

[mAc Chaos]

With nothing but his wit, his partner-in-being-hilarious-halfjerk cops Jon and the enigmatic Second Owner of the city, Leonard Conroy, who has a bad habit of hypnotizing Douglas to get information for his private investigations, our brave coffee critic tries to solve the crime of the murders that have clear links to the supernatural, the world Douglas is entirely unfamiliar with, which his pestering Magus "friend" is the supreme authority of in the area.

This is a very long, comma filled sentence.

But yeah, I second the +1.

[Christemo]

This is a very long, comma filled sentence.

But yeah, I second the +1.

I suffer from commaitis. Its a cruel mistress.

[mAc Chaos]

I only noticed it because I have to go back and rewrite sentences a lot because they end up filled with 500 commas because it sounds more natural when spoken that way.

[Fafnir]

I only noticed it because I have to go back and rewrite sentences a lot because they end up filled with 500 commas because it sounds more natural when spoken that way.

I thought I was alone in this!

[Fan_Fic_Reader]

+1 to The World Without, by Lunaludus Scribex

As much I hate what happened to Shirou and Taiga, the story is very thrilling to read. Plus it gives a good way for Shirou to have a Illya route(Other than the much safer fanfic for Shirou, Chaos Theory) since Shirou learns the harsh truth from Illya's backstory and pain, on the plus side Illya learns Shirou's life. The characters are in character, having good reasons why they act that way.
https://allthetropes.orain.org/wiki/...ht/Fanfic_Recs
Has more reviews.

[Fan_Fic_Reader]

+1 to Just An Unorthodox Thief by The Infamous Man

[Rafflesiac]

+1 to Just An Unorthodox Thief by The Infamous Man

I think that's the first rec for it, unless it's in the short story section for some reason.

You'll need a summary and a link.

[TheInfamousMan]

Thanks for the rec though!

[Fafnir]

It's the first rec? WHAT

Write a synopsis so I can +1 it.

[Phearo]

I'd recommend A Magus in Aincrad, but how many chapters should a fic have before it should be at least presentable? Because it's very recent.

[Rgal]

I'd recommend A Magus in Aincrad, but how many chapters should a fic have before it should be at least presentable? Because it's very recent.

Doesn't matter. If you think it's rec-worthy, rec it. You can always derec it later if it becomes an unholy monstrosity that threatens to consume all that is living.

[mAc Chaos]

I think that's the first rec for it, unless it's in the short story section for some reason.

You'll need a summary and a link.

Wow, I had no idea it hadn't been recced yet or I would've done it ages ago.

[Imperial]

I'd recommend A Magus in Aincrad, but how many chapters should a fic have before it should be at least presentable? Because it's very recent.

It doesn't matter.

I've recced stories as early as their second chapter. By the same token, I once recommended something at eight chapters that I later regretted once it went in a direction I disliked.

Edit: Well, it's a Sword Art Online crossover. That's something I'm never reading.