Search:

Okay, good to know that I'm not just grasping at an idea and that others think it could work.

So one thought I had: Brynhildr from Fate/Prototype is a Lancer, and is stated as also being able to be a Rider. But do you think she could conceivably serve as a Shielder in a story instead? ...

Is there a more specific source detailing that depiction? I wouldn't imagine that present-day Fuyuki receives particular attention in Apocrypha, other than how the Grail was stolen from it and maybe...

Or too much gushing and not enough criticism.

You would, though FF.net isn't the best place to get useful feedback, or authors/readers who maintain a good respect for the source material's mechanics. Still, I'm glad that I'm at least thinking...

Yeah, as much as few contrived coincidences can be tolerated, the reader's suspension of disbelief can only be pushed so far before it breaks.

A somewhat above average number of circuits, if I remember correctly, but poor ones. While this could suggest some lost Magus ancestry, it could just as well be a mutation rather than something...

I think they phrased it as a precocious crush on Shirou's side and then yandere obsession subsequent to Blackening on Jeanne's side in the next war, but either way it didn't sit right with me.
...

Kind of. They were pushing really hard for 4th War Ruler Jeanne x Master!Young Shirou. Granted, the Einzbern could hack the Grail to get a Ruler class, as they did in the Apocrypha timeline, and...

The person I was conversing with did give me some good ideas on how to revamp the story. But then there were other "gems", such as Emiya Shirou being a gifted mage who served as a Master in this...

For instance, if I'm trying to mesh Fate/Stay Night and Fate/Prototype together, someone suggests throwing Class Cards from Prisma Illya into it too. That doesn't work, from an inconsistent...

People trying to cross over too many mechanically conflicting ideas.

It's been a long time since I've been on the sight, so I'm not really informed about how the story's been going, but [x] Ayaka Sajyou

Someone brought up my old Fate/Proto Crossing story in a PM the other day. After two years, I had pretty much left it for dead, but that PM revived my interest in the project. Though I'd probably...

[x] Have him supply a vial of blood, and take it to Mahoutokoro so a wand can be made for him
[x] Tanuki
[x] Matou Shinji

[x] Tell him to buy one from Ollivander's

That is, unless he's willing to pay a steep price. We know that there are places where you can bargain for rare or powerful goods, but they demand...

Either flip a coin (or have Atram do so himself in-story) or choose what you think's funnier.

Let's go with #3!

[x] Do nothing; focus on Tanuki hunt

Or maybe it's that as a goddess, Ishtar (and her fellow deities) established the laws, and is hence considered lawful herself. In rebelling against her, Gil's alignment is naturally chaotic.

Nicely done.

Sakura's part did well on playing off Rin's insecurities (I am a Shadow, the true self... well, not really), but I think the encounter will shape Rin for the better.

I'm also...

Hmmm... Sakura is a risky proposition. It's certainly a chance to work out some long-standing psychological issues, but highly damaging to her psyche in the sort term. Though it does seem plausible...

[X] London

[X] Mashu (Manor, London)
[X] Tohsaka (Manor, London)

I don't really care on the first one so [x] No one in particular

[x] Rin, Luna, Harry


We build on the (hopeful) successes of the meeting with Rin (though I still think the group's advice to...

And of course, any such Zero Escape RP requires a death game of some sort and plenty of escape rooms.

And the mastermind's motives should be complex.