Questions, questions and more questions (READ THE OP FOR ANSWERS)

[You]

Something I've been thinking about after reading some archer gil arguments.

Suppose if say, in an alternate set of universes where the Throne's only heroic spirit is Gilgamesh, meaning no other heroes and no other NPs exist,

That can't happen because there are events that produce heroic spirits which are quantum time locked.

[castor212]

, in an alternate set of universes where the Throne's only heroic spirit is Gilgamesh,

Throne outside timeline tho

[Ahnibal]

Does anyone of the KoTR ever react to Mash's shield and realize her Saint Graph's identity? (playing global)

[Altaris]

Most of them did yes

[Ahnibal]

Ah good, thanks.

[AvengerEmiya]

In Hollow Ataraxia, where do Gil and Lancer live?

[Marmadillo]

lancer is a hobo that sleeps on the pier
gil has the original bed in the gate

[Iceblade44]

gil has the original bed in the gate

Either that or he has a room in the water park

[Akyuu]

That can't happen because there are events that produce heroic spirits which are quantum time locked.

Throne outside timeline tho

thats why i said alternate set of universes but i guess that doesnt make sense. i dont know, what if the throne only had gil?

thinking on it that was a much more direct way to ask the question

[SpoonyViking]

I imagine he would still have everything he had in his treasury when he was alive.

[neveron]

Gil isn't limited to noble phantasms - it's more like "all of humanity's achievements", IIRC.

And yeah, he still gathered up a bunch of stuff while he was alive.

[LeadDemon]

thats why i said alternate set of universes but i guess that doesnt make sense. i dont know, what if the throne only had gil?

thinking on it that was a much more direct way to ask the question

Part of his shtick is "owns every legend". The other part is:

03 - Collector [EX]
The ability to acquire items of higher quality. It's the good luck of frequently obtaining even rare items, but because it only applies to Gilgamesh himself, it does not bless the Master. Gilgamesh is a collector of treasure. "I collected all the treasures of the earth," is Gilgamesh's favorite phrase, but that is not a metaphor. He collected and stored away a sample of all the technology that was developed during his age and sealed them.
That which Gilgamesh stored, rather than being treasure, is "the origin of the intelligence of mankind" itself. If it does not exist in Gilgamesh's treasury, then it is "something produced by a new breed of humanity, according a completely new concept," "something made from the technology of the culture born from the intelligent life from another heavenly body," one of the two. For that reason, of course he has airplanes and submarines. The desires of the people from before Christ are not different, and it would not do for the crafts of ancient times when magic was in good health to be inferior to the crafts of the modern age.
People generally realize the "tools of hope" that they dream of, and each time that occurs, it ended with them being confiscated by the king's hand. The offensive skill Gilgamesh uses, "Gate of Babylon," shoots the treasure he collected like this like arrows. The gate to the golden capital opens, and his treasures are shot out from his treasure cellar.
This is a digression, but after the Noble Phantasms that are shot out are used, regardless of how far it has gone, it turns to Gilgamesh's treasure cellar. "Hah. I possess a Noble Phantasm which excels at the task of retrieval," says the person himself.

[Trubo]

What if Medea won the HGW? Could she create an even better Grail?

From what I remember, she already knows what's in the grail, so she wouldn't be making any wishes. She could still funnel the energy in it to do whatever she'd want though, so I guess just live with Kuzuki until he dies.

[Marmadillo]

why am i convinced she'd go full extella tamamo

[FourthWall]

Because Medea was the original waifu Caster.

[Sesto]

From what I remember, she already knows what's in the grail

where was this said

[You]

where was this said

"…It is all for the Holy Grail. It is natural for me to go crazy for something that can grant any wish."
That is a lie.
She knows the true identity of the Holy Grail.
She already knows what that thing is and why Servants like her are summoned.

…It is true that most wishes can be granted using the Holy Grail that appears in this town.
It will allow her to stay in this world with physical form, and it will allow her to start a second life as a "human".
But.

"How stupid. There is no meaning in such a thing."
Saying so, she closes her eyes.
She empties her mind.
For nowshe lets her guard down and rests her mind.

[Desuclocker]

That sounds like Medea knows the purpose of the ritual, not the fact that Angra's inside.

[SeiKeo]

"Why Servants like her are summoned" is directly calling out how AM corruption allows for antiheroes.

[Arha]

Yeah I don't read that as her knowing the grail has been corrupted.