Questions, questions and more questions (READ THE OP FOR ANSWERS)

[~Freedom]

Ok, so same timeline. What about the flowchart? Not enough infos?

[Arashi_Leonhart]

You want a flowchart for how stuff connects?

Mahoyo --> Tsuki --> Fate

Rakkyo

Extra

Notes
Tsuki no Sango

DDD

[eddyak]

DDD's a little too close, you need a few extra pages of paragraph breaks.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

I didn't wanna be too obnoxious.

[Haseo Nanaya]

To get an actual timeline it involves a starting point. Knowledge of Japanese school systems (i.e. HnM doesn't give any time but it does give a timescale of a school year.), character ages, and other stuff. With that it should be easy to construct a timeline.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

The only real thing we know for sure is

Mahoyo = Late 80s
Fate/Zero = 1994 or 1995
Tsukihime = Early 2000s
Fate/stay night = 2004 or 2005


Kara no Kyoukai = Mid 90s


Assuming Tsuki and Fate are literally "Tsukihime's fall storyline ends, Fate's winter storyline begins" then it puts Tsuki the calendar year before FSN but the same "school year" in that Shirou and Shiki are the same age. But then again Tsuki's actual dates don't line up with those years. But then again FSN's don't either.

Have fun!

[Rafflesiac]

F/SN got confirmed for 2004 in the anime.

[~Freedom]

The only real thing we know for sure is

Mahoyo = Late 80s
Fate/Zero = 1994 or 1995
Tsukihime = Early 2000s
Fate/stay night = 2004 or 2005


Kara no Kyoukai = Mid 90s


Assuming Tsuki and Fate are literally "Tsukihime's fall storyline ends, Fate's winter storyline begins" then it puts Tsuki the calendar year before FSN but the same "school year" in that Shirou and Shiki are the same age. But then again Tsuki's actual dates don't line up with those years. But then again FSN's don't either.

Have fun!

That's exactly what I feared. Hoped here I could find some more detaleid information. Damn you Nasu.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

F/SN got confirmed for 2004 in the anime.

Saber also confirmed to be able to stab Herk in the anime, so yeah, I'm just gonna stick to this.

[Cruor]

Arashi: people rationalized after that statement was made that the 'after Tsukihime ends FSN begins' doesn't necessarily mean it happened right after but coulda been years.

KnK happened from like 1994/1995-1998 and 2008.

Then we have that line in MBAA that Ryougi calls herself Shiki's sempai with the eyes when Shiki had them 10 (wait, was it 6 or 8?) years before the start of Tsukihime. Which makes no sense whether it be 1999/2000/2003 etc.

- - - Updated - - -

Saber also confirmed to be able to stab Herk in the anime, so yeah, I'm just gonna stick to this.

F/z takes place in 1993 or 1994 that was well known. And FSN takes place 10 years after F/z

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Yes I know, which is why that whole "but if this is so Tsuki dates don't line up" thing goes in there, ktnx

[SeiKeo]

Arashi: people rationalized after that statement was made that the 'after Tsukihime ends FSN begins' doesn't necessarily mean it happened right after but coulda been years.

KnK happened from like 1994/1995-1998 and 2008.

Then we have that line in MBAA that Ryougi calls herself Shiki's sempai with the eyes when Shiki had them 10 (wait, was it 6 or 8?) years before the start of Tsukihime. Which makes no sense whether it be 1999/2000/2003 etc.

- - - Updated - - -



F/z takes place in 1993 or 1994 that was well known. And FSN takes place 10 years after F/z

Who says sempai is temporal?

[Polly]

There's already been an argument about timelines.

From Tsukihime's own text it can be deduced that the story takes place in 2000/2001, but then there's Nasu statement that F/SN starts at the ending of Tsuki so there's that.

[Rafflesiac]

Saber also confirmed to be able to stab Herk in the anime, so yeah, I'm just gonna stick to this.

*opens mouth*

...

Fair enough.

[Mcjon01]

Who says sempai is temporal?

死を語るのは十年早い。いや、三年遅いかな。■この眼に関しちゃこっちの方が先輩だぜ、色男。

Ryougi.

[forumghost]

There's already been an argument about timelines.

From Tsukihime's own text it can be deduced that the story takes place in 2000/2001, but then there's Nasu statement that F/SN starts at the ending of Tsuki so there's that.

The end of Tsukihime is the epilogue, which occurs an indeterminate amount of time after any of the main Routes.

[~Freedom]

Sorry if I still ask, but I'm kinda a newbie, and english is not my first language.

"Other than the existence of the Moon Cell itself, the world of Fate/Stay Night is said to be exactly the same up until the 1970s"

So here is basically saying that despite the presence of the Moon Cell (thus making it a totally different timeline) until the '70s the events are the same happened in the main Fate Timeline?
Sorry If I'm keeping bothering you.

[Haseo Nanaya]

If you guys want to talk timelines, give Hana no Miyako a try. I swear Zelritch must have been drunk.
1) it's at least 16 years after because Kuzuki has a kid.
2) it can't be more then 5 years after melty since Miyako just entered highschool.
3) it's at least 10 years since Tsukihime since Akiha has grown up.
4) It's either set before F/Z or in Prillya since Kirigutsu is alive.
5) etc

yeah.... Let's just not bother with Type-Moon timelines.

[Megas]

If you guys want to talk timelines, give Hana no Miyako a try. I swear Zelritch must have been drunk.
1) it's at least 16 years after because Kuzuki has a kid.
2) it can't be more then 5 years after melty since Miyako just entered highschool.
3) it's at least 10 years since Tsukihime since Akiha has grown up.
4) It's either set before F/Z or in Prillya since Kirigutsu is alive.
5) etc

yeah.... Let's just not bother with Type-Moon timelines.

So, uh, why are you using a doujin that Nasu likes as a timeline representative?

[Arashi_Leonhart]

The end of Tsukihime is the epilogue, which occurs an indeterminate amount of time after any of the main Routes.

It's just one of these things where Nasu'll say "It was this" like it was always so but really he's just been updating stuff in his head since then. Like how Carnival Phantasm gave Shirou a Bluray when in Take Moon it was a DVDR or something.

I mean, otherwise the grail needing sixty years is also off between war 3 and 4, unless it was actually "Well, 60 years, give or take a decade."