Type-Moon Fanfic Idea Thread

[Delcer]

...You know this discussion wants me to try to do an experiment.
One fic made entirely with OC's (That I already have)
One fic with no OC's whatsoever involved (That I'm planning)
And one with a of OC's and Main Characters.
Just to see the results and the reception these types get.

Don't bother, that's a waste of time. Just find some wannabe author on FFN and search the stories in their profile.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Actually, I sorta understand the logic behind not using Shiki/Shirou as the mains for the porn idea.

Me too, though if I were to write something like that, I'd probably be using second person "you" and leaving it ambiguous as to whether we're talking about the set protags or letting your own imagination as the reader go wild to let the reader make up their minds on that angle. I've seen that happen a couple of times in fanfiction somewhat effectively, anyway.

[Spinach]

Yeah, but we all know you're a whore.

I will burn you alive.

Spy is a mean person.

[TheSpy]

Spy is a mean person.

Only when people do things that annoy me.

The rest of the time, I am a generous and caring soul.

[keeper13]

A world in Fate where Ayaka Sajyou's the protagonist instead of Shirou, along with her Servant, (Prototype) Saber. Sakura remains in the Tohsaka Family and help her sister Rin and her Servant Archer (Gilgamesh or Archerko (Ilya who decided to furfill her father's wish)). Bazett is still alive and still the Master of Lancer. Shinji has Magic Circuits and became Master of (True) Assassin/Hassan. Luvia's now part of the war with Berserker. Caster didn't meet Kuzuki b/c she's still the Servant to her original Master, who is still alive, and also summon her own Servant, Rider. Caren takes over her late father's place as the Mediator.

As for Kiritsugu and Ilya, they summoned Avenger (or only Ilya summon Avenger, with Kiritsugu passed away or something, IDK).

[eddyak]

Me too, though if I were to write something like that, I'd probably be using second person "you" and leaving it ambiguous as to whether we're talking about the set protags or letting your own imagination as the reader go wild to let the reader make up their minds on that angle. I've seen that happen a couple of times in fanfiction somewhat effectively, anyway.

Sounds too much like those choose-your-own-adventure books to me. I've always hated those.

[I3uster]

Is this an idea? Just asking because you kinda throw it in there without an introduction.

[Sherrinford]

A world in Fate where Ayaka Sajyou's the protagonist instead of Shirou, along with her Servant, (Prototype) Saber. Sakura remains in the Tohsaka Family and help her sister Rin and her Servant Archer (Gilgamesh). Bazett is still alive and still the Master of Lancer. Shinji has Magic Circuits and became Master of (True) Assassin/Hassan. Luvia's now part of the war with Berserker. Caster didn't meet Kuzuki b/c she's still the Servant to her original Master, who is still alive, and also summon her own Servant, Rider. Caren takes over her late father's place as the Mediator.

As for Kiritsugu and Ilya, they summoned Avenger (or only Ilya summon Avenger, with Kiritsugu passed away or something).

It was good until you brought in Avenger, IMO.

[Spinach]

Only when people do things that annoy me.

The rest of the time, I am a generous and caring soul.

Y'know what, I dislike conflicts. So, with that in mind, can you just give me a list of all the things that annoy you so that I can never do them, and thus never have any conflicts with you?

So far I have:
Yuri
Yaoi
Exclusion of Shirou
Original characters
Not pairing Saber with Shirou

Anything else?

[Delcer]

Me too, though if I were to write something like that, I'd probably be using second person "you" and leaving it ambiguous as to whether we're talking about the set protags or letting your own imagination as the reader go wild to let the reader make up their minds on that angle. I've seen that happen a couple of times in fanfiction somewhat effectively, anyway.

Oh, so are you saying that his OC is most likely modeled to be a fictional persona of himself? That this is some sort of subtle form of self insert that allows you to avoid tagging it as such, yet gives you a brief fighting chance at defending your OC to be anything other than a Sue? Because that's what I usually understand it to be.

[I3uster]

Sakura and Archer.

[Spinach]

Sakura and Archer.

Added to list~

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Sounds too much like those choose-your-own-adventure books to me. I've always hated those.

You mean, like this Tsukihime and Fate/stay night thing where you read through a story that could either end in terrible deaths or a continuing of the adventure depending on narrative choices you make as the main character? ^_^

[keeper13]

It was good until you brought in Avenger, IMO.

Yeah, I was still thinking of what would Ilya's role will be, since Luvia got her Berserker.

But I did think that Ilya will take Shirou's role of pursuing her Father's ideal of being the Hero of Justice, which may lead her into becoming Archerko (mayber Servant Arher for Rin and Sakura)

[Erlkonig]

I will burn you alive.

Now that's just bullshit. One fic made up entirely of Original Characters is no different than Fate itself, it's merely a story weaved base on the Nasuverse- Heck, he never even said it was in Nasuverse, so it could just be an Original Setting which by the way is no different than say, Nasuverse, Harry Potter, or w/e.

quality might vary though, that I can admit

[Sherrinford]

@keeper13:

Carification:

It was good = it may or may not work, with such a premise you have to work with the characterization.

Avenger = I have nothing against him at all, but Avenger must be already dead in order for someone to summon heroes such has Caster.

Although, I (never having played F/HA) always liked the idea of a plotting-behind-the-curtains Avenger (kinda like Gilgamesh).

[eddyak]

You mean, like this Tsukihime and Fate/stay night thing where you read through a story that could either end in terrible deaths or a continuing of the adventure depending on narrative choices you make as the main character? ^_^

Which don't automatically assume it's you in the dungeon and make your choices for you, where you don't have to sit around scribbling hp and stats after every roll of a dice and where you don't get annoyed with the sheer amount of stupid choices and eventually end up with every finger wedged into a separate open page because you're reading ahead to see which option will get you to finish the damn end faster.

[Arashi_Leonhart]

Well, when you put it like that...

[nununu]

Sounds too much like those choose-your-own-adventure books to me. I've always hated those.

Hey! I remember those when I was a kid!

[lantzblades]

Oh, so are you saying that his OC is most likely modeled to be a fictional persona of himself?

it doesn't matter what he's saying. such is not the case. he and i are nothing alike nor would i ever paint myself up in such a fashion. the fanfiction community has too many DJ crofts as it is.