Tsukihime Remake Thread - NOT THE SPOILER THREAD

[Nanaya]

Even though they are different worlds with mutually exclusive plot points...

- - - Updated - - -

Speaking of, does this mean Tsukihime worlds Count of Monte Cristo was pure fiction, or that Dantes failed to destroy Roa?

/Shrug, Roa meeting Arc is probably enough to change his life regardless if Dantes exists. I would assume he does exist and they never cross paths since Arc would probably have killed Roa beforehand or any number of reasons. It's entirely possible Dantes would be killed in this timeline if they had since the worlds are different enough.

[Skull]

If they ever make a Tsuki/FGO collab then a rematch between Dantes and Roa needs to happen.

[weeblord]

Shiki vs herc rematch pog

[Rafflesiac]

can't wait for that 17-hit quick np

[Nanaya]

Tsuki/FGO will probably happen because of $ but the scenario would probably be wack in all honesty. They'd have to be AU of the characters and it's probably a stretch for any of them to really appear in that setting. You can shoehorn Ciel and Arc anywhere because of their power but even then... I wonder if Nasu would write it.

[Pendant]

Tsuki/FGO will probably happen because of $ but the scenario would probably be wack in all honesty. They'd have to be AU of the characters and it's probably a stretch for any of them to really appear in that setting. You can shoehorn Ciel and Arc anywhere because of their power but even then... I wonder if Nasu would write it.

Asagami is a Servant somehow. Where there's a will there's a way.

[Nanaya]

Asagami is a Servant somehow. Where there's a will there's a way.

Where there is $ to be had, they'll force it lol.

[OnesFleetingGlory]

Only Tohno is the true Master of Temptress, and no one else. Unless they pull a Gatou scenario, which I'm strongly against.

[Nanaya]

Only Tohno is the true Master of Temptress, and no one else. Unless they pull a Gatou scenario, which I'm strongly against.

It would be pretty off-putting to have a valentines event with the girls lol. Even if they were AU. I imagine they'd do something similar to what they did with Ryougi and Void which wasn't the greatest. That would be even weirder in Arc's case because I swear I remember Shiki/Ciel saying something somewhere about that aspect just being another part of who Arc is. And I remember Archetype being affected by Shiki's death.

[Twelveseal]

Tbh, you don't have to be especially AU. This is a setting with Singularities where something goes so utterly wrong it breaks reality, and where Alaya can theoretically make a Counter Guardian of anyone.

[Bobin]

I have to wonder how much of the distinguishment being made between Tsuki and Fate has to do with whatever major changes are going to be revealed in the remake. It's something that keeps bugging me whenever I think about the weirdness of TsukiRe taking place in modern society with smartphones and now takes place after many previous works chronologically.

[Nanaya]

Tbh, you don't have to be especially AU. This is a setting with Singularities where something goes so utterly wrong it breaks reality, and where Alaya can theoretically make a Counter Guardian of anyone.

Now that I think of it, are the KnK crew in FGO the ones that we know from the novels? Did their world get affected by the bullshit or is it that they're just similar characters from a similar timeline.

[CielWorstGirl]

If Satsuki was gonna get a route then they would have listed her CV along with the heroines.

[Mattias]

Speaking of, does this mean Tsukihime worlds Count of Monte Cristo was pure fiction, or that Dantes failed to destroy Roa?

Presumably, yeah. Arc must have flattened him here.

Or... Arc herself is the Count(ess).

[Twelveseal]

Or... Arc herself is the Count(ess).

This is legitimately terrifying, mindboggling, and awesome. Goth chuuni Arc? Yes. But how the hell do you explain it?

[migliole]

I would presume human history fiction is non-existent on Tsukihime because DAA wouldn't allow history itself to be in the first place. Therefore, the Count or even Arthoria didn't happen or stayed as irrelevant events, for whatever DAA related reason.

At least this is how I interpret the Tsukihime and Fate worlds separation made by the Nasu Blog.

Fate = Humanity affirmation.
Tsukihime = Whatever is not affirming humanity.

The first thing that came to my mind is the non-existence of Alaya, which implied the non-existence of the Throne, or, at least, a weakened Alaya that can only powerup humans but not create a record of them to use when things go worse than expected.

That is, things like a empowering individuals will happen, but it won't be as heroic, probably won't have mixed Gaia things (like having a Holy Sword) and those individuals won't be marked on history to create a collective record of symbols that could be used again.

Anyway, this is all speculation and we will probably have the answer by summer.

[Twelveseal]

Pretty sure a deviation that extreme constitutes a Lostbelt.

[SirGauoftheSquareTable]

I personally hcd that the deviation only really became apparent post-AoG, so heroes like Artoria/Arthuria wouldn't be affected, since Britain is still the navel of the planet and the last place where the AoG ended, at least in Eurasia. Also, as long as humanity is in danger/needs protection, Alaya would probably exist. The conditions would have to be like SIN for Alaya to become totally inactive.

[TomPen94]

I'm so lost... May I ask where the Count of Monte Cristo stuff, AoG and Alaya come from?
I know I've been acting like a real elitist but I've never gone beyond the bigger VNs and some of the anime in the Nasuverse.
I intend to fix that though.

[Nanaya]

When Shiki dashes through that Zombie... does he actually kill the whole horde in that instant or at least multiple of them? That feels like the sort of ridiculous shit Shiki got up to in the OG VN and I noticed what looked like multiple kills.