Fate/Grand Order General Discussion (CONTAINS SPOILERS)

[Laith]

What did AA do wrong?

Made him kinda incompetent and Watson was the brains of the operation most of the time.

Watson is a 10 year old girl.

[LegalLoliLover]

Mata Hari probably won a grail war in the past and wished for retroactively larger boobs.

A 1-star winning the war? Not the GO or Apocrypha team battles, but single combat?

Made him kinda incompetent and Watson was the brains of the operation most of the time.

Watson is a 10 year old girl.

Gosick?

[Ratman]

Or they could just have the history be different? Faust and Mephistopheles are fictitious figures, but they're treated as real IIRC?

Dr. Faustus was definitely real. The core of the story about a weird alchemist who blew himself up and people said the devil took him through the hole in the roof is real.

The idea is probably that Goethe, being honestly one of the smartest people of his time, could have been privy to some additional information. It's more of a stretch than Moby Dick or Frankenstein being based on a true story, which aren't a stretch at all given how the stories are framed.

[GundamFSN]

Made him kinda incompetent and Watson was the brains of the operation most of the time.

Watson is a 10 year old girl.

Wow..this may actually happen to Sherlock.

It'll be like the Memocho girl I bet.

[GDB]

I can accept a Sherlock gender bending, but I cannot accept a lolification. Read too many stories of him doing his thing at an opium den, or disguising as a beggar, etc. A loli just cannot fit that image in my mind. I feel like we need a small to moderate breasted late 20's/early 30's woman.

I'm not sure how I'd feel about a shotafication, since it'd be an obvious shout-out to Detective Conan.

[Ratman]

I want them to pull a Caesar again, actually. I want them to give him action-genre movie-Poirot makeover.

More importantly, that silly hat they always draw him with needs to go.

[Kotonoha]

Isn't Nasu Drake suspected to be Elizabeth I?

She might be but also might not be.

[LegalLoliLover]

I can accept a Sherlock gender bending, but I cannot accept a lolification. Read too many stories of him doing his thing at an opium den, or disguising as a beggar, etc.

Child beggar... So basically, like the many orphans in the streets during those days?

[Zork Knight]

Oliver Twist was Holmes in disguise all along

[Ratman]

But that would give Oliver Twist some retroactive literary value as at least a biography, and I am not sure I can deal with that.

Social realism my ass. That wasn't no Dostoyevsky, and it sure wasn't no Hrabal, either.

[Rafflesiac]

More importantly, that silly hat they always draw him with needs to go.

Nah, they just need to make it tiny, like CCC Tamamo's idol top hat.

- - - Updated - - -

Magical Mystery ☆ Holly-Chan, here to solve the mysteries of love and justice!

[Ratman]

I wanted to say that would make him a Touhou but then I realized it's not necessarily so.

But then you updated the post with the caption which would definitely make him a Touhou.

[Renko]

Finally! Hassan can really do some work with his hand.

[rxrx]

I want Robert Downey Jr Sherlock Holmes as Caster with a gun partnered with Nursery Rhymes in book form as caster to lay the smackdown on Assassin Jack the Ripper

[Nobody]

If we do get a Sherlock than I just want him to be a man.

[GundamFSN]

Same

Along with

Spoiler:

Musashi

[Spartacus]

Shota Sherlock vs Phantom of The Opera.
Aka Conan vs Kaitou Kid.

[Crown]

[Zork Knight]

London is us, Sherlock, Nursery Rhyme and Shakespeare going through the city solving crimes. Multiple villains acting independently. That's my dream.

Don't let my dreams be dreams, DW.

[Rafflesiac]

I dig it.