Originally Posted by
Kariya
Fate 2006 it's the best and more faithful adaptation of all F/SN anime adaptations. It's not a mix of all routes, it's Fate route with little pieces of another routes in order to give all characters background, and another extra complementary scenes that did not show in the original vn.
The movie of UBW it's not perfect, but still it's much better and faithful than UBW tv UFO version.
It's a pitty that DEEN did not animate the other two routes, UBW and HF like Fate route, with a TV series for each one.
I did never understand too that hate to DEEN, when they did the best anime works of F/SN, and i did never understand why the people call 2006 Fate a mix of three routes, if we call it a mix, we should call UBW tv UFO version a mix of UBW, Fate and Extra CCC too, but anyway i suposse that each one have his opinion, as this is mine.
About Tsukihime anime, i think that it's not bad, the only problem i see it's the pace, a bit slow to me. The general tone was different than the vn, but still i think it was not bad.