I'm about to finish Tsukihime (finally), and after I'm done, I plan to do what I did after finishing Fate/stay Night - watch the anime.
I began with DEEN's adaptation first. Despite what I kept hearing about their version being terrible, I really liked it. Yeah, the mixing of routes was weird, but give DEEN a break. Type-Moon wasn't as "big" back then. They had no idea that all three routes would get to be adapted individually. That never happens, even for super popular VNs. Of course they're going to jam as much stuff in there as they possibly can. I never got why people called this adaptation "garbage" because of that.
Similarity, I never got why people will literally act like they caught amnesia when the Tsukihime anime was brought up.
So, what the dealio? Is it really that bad, or are people just being people again?