Unpopular TM opinions you have

[You]

Burial Agency files, main-but-not-too-main character status, suitable for action and exposition, connections to literally everyone........hard to think of anyone like that......

Consider Dawn has memory problems and Merem is a demonic Peter Pan.

[Leftovers]

Consider Dawn has memory problems and Merem is a demonic Peter Pan.

But can Dawn play baseball?

[You]

But can Dawn play baseball?

In England, S v S is played with one batsman, one bowler, and one dismissal.

[Leftovers]

In England, S v S is played with one batsman, one bowler, and one dismissal.

I see, then his friendly rival Ciel must've learned the art of batting from the retired MVP, Cricket de Marche.

[Dullahan]

They play cricket in India, don't they?

[HumanComplex]

In FGO, almost nothing was shown besides them not being affected by the Bleaching, which doesn’t really reveal much. In case files, I reiterate my point that it’s probably just a mage or two personally involved with Ergo, it likely won’t delve deep into the political structure of the WS. Perhaps I worded my rant too strongly, I simply dislike how TM treated the WS so far.

Here’s to hoping WS will be treated properly going forward in CS, instead of TM avoiding them again.

[TheSeaDragon]

im re viisting UBW anime and..i will just say it , regards some stuff, and i mean important stuff , Sudo did a better job wit hf tan Miura did here

Maybe a hot take? Thats why i place it here

[Altima of the Gates]

I appreciated the added bits, but some things could have been done way better in UBW, like regarding the Einzbern homunculi was a little too quick

[mami-kouga]

im re viisting UBW anime and..i will just say it , regards some stuff, and i mean important stuff , Sudo did a better job wit hf tan Miura did here

Maybe a hot take? Thats why i place it here

I don't think that's particularly a hot take considering novel readers have issues with both adaptations. The main point of difference between the two would be the increased main heroine focus and the fact that HF was a movie and thus things would inevitably be condensed

- - - Updated - - -

I'm not a novel reader so aside from my criticisms towards the end of movie 3 being incomprehensible without source reader explanation I also can't particularly get mad at it after dealing with Camelot movies which shows there are WAY worse things that can happen than you're favourite scenes not being in the movie

[Byegod]

My take is fate fans will never be happy with any adaption ngl

[OnesFleetingGlory]

Can't please them all. Instead, they got better chance in attracting as many fans as possible with diverse spinoffs. You know, different strokes for different folks.

[pinetree]

My take is fate fans will never be happy with any adaption ngl

Emiya Gohan is great and well liked.
Apo is a pretty good adaptation, I don't recall that much complaining, aside from the super loud sound effects.

[Herod]

Apo is a pretty good adaptation, I don't recall that much complaining, aside from the super loud sound effects.

That's because people were complaining about Apo as story in itself.

[Takashi]

I don't think that's particularly a hot take considering novel readers have issues with both adaptations. The main point of difference between the two would be the increased main heroine focus and the fact that HF was a movie and thus things would inevitably be condensed

- - - Updated - - -

I'm not a novel reader so aside from my criticisms towards the end of movie 3 being incomprehensible without source reader explanation I also can't particularly get mad at it after dealing with Camelot movies which shows there are WAY worse things that can happen than you're favourite scenes not being in the movie

Tbh if you watched Kara no kyoukai. It's not hard to deduce that touko just made another body for shirou. The thing that was unexplained was how they found shirou or shirou's soul there.

[Dullahan]

it dropped from him like an item pickup in dark souls. rin just walked over his corpse and saw the prompt

[fumei]

Apo is a pretty good adaptation, I don't recall that much complaining, aside from the super loud sound effects.

It really wasn't. The only reason not many people complained is because most people couldn't even have read it fully, or had just chosen to not read it because it was unfinished and/or they just bandwagoned on "apo bad" before the anime even came out.

[Reign]

The anime completely cut out the reason Atalanta went crazy at the end lol

I think the Gilles stuff was changed a bit too.

- - - Updated - - -

Removing Gordes' order for Siegfried to be mute was a good change though

[pinetree]

It really wasn't. The only reason not many people complained is because most people couldn't even have read it fully, or had just chosen to not read it because it was unfinished and/or they just bandwagoned on "apo bad" before the anime even came out.

Sure, I haven't read it fully, but going off the volumes that were translated I don't remember any egregious changes.
The only thing is Siegfried saying his name but I think that's pretty much it.

- - - Updated - - -

Oh yeah also Achilles not crying, but I didn't care much.

[Byegod]

I mean I'll be real, The sound effects literally did hurt my ears

[Mattias]

And they made it even worse in Babylonia.