Mahou Senki: Lyrical Days (FSN x Nanoha Crossover)

[crystalwatcher]

I hope they don't <.<

[Carpe_Noctem]

The chapter was finished last night. I have to do my own first draft editing, mostly thematic stuff before sending it to the Beta.

Awesomesauce
Now to re-read the last chapter so I remember what happened. *goes back to read*

[Daneel Rush]

Uhh...Thoma x Lily is pretty much canon and it would be ridiculous for them not to be considered a definite couple. I don't see how you can claim he's being 'put on a bus' as you say it.

And what's the deal with Vivio having an Adult Form? It's not like she was the first; it's manga canon that Vita can do it as well, she's just never been shown using it.

[Kyte]

And what's the deal with Vivio having an Adult Form? It's not like she was the first; it's manga canon that Vita can do it as well, she's just never been shown using it.

If we don't see it it doesn't count. Also anime canon's in a higher tier than manga canon.

[qsurf]

If we don't see it it doesn't count. Also anime canon's in a higher tier than manga canon.

*remembers terrible anime adaptations, entire points in manga that were left out due to time constraints...so on*

I am amused, but honestly it should really be rated as such:
1) Light/Visual Novel Canon
2) Manga Canon
3) Anime Canon

If only because it's far, far easier for things to go missing or wrong during the Anime's production.

[Santo]

*remembers terrible anime adaptations, entire points in manga that were left out due to time constraints...so on*

I am amused, but honestly it should really be rated as such:
1) Light/Visual Novel Canon
2) Manga Canon
3) Anime Canon

If only because it's far, far easier for things to go missing or wrong during the Anime's production.

This man speaks wisdom. I agree with wisdom.

[Kyte]

*remembers terrible anime adaptations, entire points in manga that were left out due to time constraints...so on*

I am amused, but honestly it should really be rated as such:
1) Light/Visual Novel Canon
2) Manga Canon
3) Anime Canon

If only because it's far, far easier for things to go missing or wrong during the Anime's production.

Tiers of canon don't work that way. It's not a quality issue, it's closeness to the original work. The original work itself is Tier 1 canon. Word of God and such is usually Tier 2 canon, Adapted works is Tier 3 canon, Licensed is Tier 4, etc.
Nanoha was born an anime and got adapted to manga, so the anime is higher tier than manga.

[qsurf]

Tiers of canon don't work that way. It's not a quality issue, it's closeness to the original work. The original work itself is Tier 1 canon. Word of God and such is usually Tier 2 canon, Adapted works is Tier 3 canon, Licensed is Tier 4, etc.
Nanoha was born an anime and got adapted to manga, so the anime is higher tier than manga.

The manga fleshed out what was happening in the anime.

Questions?

[lethum]

Lies. The manga contains enough incompatible details to prevent it from being the same continuity as the anime. Or maybe not. Truths.

[Kyte]

The manga fleshed out what was happening in the anime.

Questions?

You're still misunderstanding the entire concept, which I won't bother explaining further 'cause the previous post said it all.

[runewizarddd]

*Joke Post* I view the A's manga Omakes as canon, so the reason Vita never uses her adult form is because she's afraid of what Hayate will due to her if she ever sees it. (I haven't read Vivid or Force).

[Muramasa]

We're getting a little off topic gents >_>


Remember this is Lyrical Days. Not the MGLN discussion thread.

[Lycodrake]

Uhh...Thoma x Lily is pretty much canon and it would be ridiculous for them not to be considered a definite couple. I don't see how you can claim he's being 'put on a bus' as you say it.

7arcs' track record. Keep that part in mind.

And what's the deal with Vivio having an Adult Form? It's not like she was the first; it's manga canon that Vita can do it as well, she's just never been shown using it.

Proof or it didn't happen. Sorry, just saying.

[YamiheKazeto]

The manga fleshed out what was happening in the anime.

Questions?

Depends on which manga. The supplementary ones are pretty high on the closeness list, but still lower than the sound stages. The movie manga (along with the movie itself), as well as ViVid and Force (both amusingly) are pretty low there. And the supplementary manga's omake is somewhere in-between - higher than the latter, but definitely lower than said manga itself, because it was mostly made for laughs.

[Lycodrake]

Depends on which manga. The supplementary ones are pretty high on the closeness list, but still lower than the sound stages. The movie manga (along with the movie itself), as well as ViVid and Force (both amusingly) are pretty low there. And the supplementary manga's omake is somewhere in-between - higher than the latter, but definitely lower than said manga itself, because it was mostly made for laughs.

The Omake contain some character bashing, thus I don't take any of them as canon. If they are? Yeah, 7arcs would reach an entirely new low.

[Muramasa]

We're getting a little off topic gents >_>


Remember this is Lyrical Days. Not the MGLN discussion thread.

Ahem.

[Lycodrake]

Ahem.

Quoting yourself is a bad habit. I did that once, but learned not to. XP
On the other hand, try and learn to deal with derails, Muramasa. Just saying. ^^;

[Kyte]

I'm pretty sure there's nothing stopping you from starting a nanoha discussion thread and linking to it. Be proactive man.

[Lycodrake]

I'm pretty sure there's nothing stopping you from starting a nanoha discussion thread and linking to it. Be proactive man.

There's already one, Kyte. ^^;

[crystalwatcher]

Just saying. ^^;

How can I hear Lyco saying this in an imitation voice to Rikku from FF?