Originally Posted by
Arete
I didn't give any of my impressions in that statement. I was saying that 'if' what you said was true, it wasn't doing a good job of it. Also I'd watched another episode by that point so no I haven't only watched just one episode, though I feel like I'd be better off if I had. So yeah, my first comment was watching just one episode, and the second one I only made one assumption but that was being generous to it, and definitely not 'a lot' of assumptions.
I definitely wouldn't call her a saint, so if that's how you took my comments then you're not understanding them properly. And yeah I'd already gathered from what you said that that's what she's supposed to be like. This ain't my first rodeo. I'm more talking about how it's all presented in the anime being pretentious and not very subtle, insulting the intelligence of the audience at times. It doesn't really present things in the best manor and I don't know that I really care enough to put in the extra work to understand what it's really trying to say, especially when I could be looking too deep and giving it more credit than it's due.
You're mistaken if you think I disagree with your points, I'm more pointing out how it's conveyed poorly, with contradictions in how it's presented. Take for example when you say that she needs to learn how to account for their feelings better, yet in the first episode we're told she's supposedly the only one that seems to care for the 86, and already takes their feelings into account. I don't say you're wrong, just that the show doesn't present it in a good way
For me it's the exact sort of show that sounds better on paper as opposed to how it's actually executed. I like some of the ideas in there (though strong emphasis on some) but there's too much suspension of disbelief I need to do to accept it to begin with. Not to mention that while understand what it can be about can be interesting for an analysis, it doesn't do all that well to retain one's focus or interest for long.
On final comment. What does it matter if I'd one watched one episode anyway? I'm far from the only one who makes impressions about what is to come based on the pilots. And I wouldn't even say that I made all that many assumptions. Most of my comment was about the problems within that one episode, of which I didn't actually list my main ones, mostly cause they amount to the same thing.