Birth of new TYPE-MOON Wiki

[Ideofago]

Honestly, the only way make a 100% indisputable TM wiki is to provide a primary source for every single statement no matter how minor and to have said primary sources available on the wiki.

There's a reason 'loremasters' can be nicknamed "nerdery phds".

[Byegod]

Honestly one issue is stuff thats in ambigious territory tbh

Like stuff that occurs but we arent told why or how

[aldeayeah]

Honestly, the only way make a 100% indisputable TM wiki is to provide a primary source for every single statement no matter how minor and to have said primary sources available on the wiki.

I mean the "main" TM wiki has improved a ton on that front

That's not the endgame though.

The endgame is a wiki where there is no original content at all, just primary sources.

Pure, sterile perfection. The TMdict guys got it right.

[Kamera]

Honestly the perfect wiki for me is something like 1d4chan

[fumei]

Honestly one issue is stuff thats in ambigious territory tbh

Like stuff that occurs but we arent told why or how

Just don't include stuff that's drawing conclusions or inference or anything. People can make their own interpretations elsewhere but just because something is ambiguous doesn't mean it can't be no a wiki, you just put all the ambiguous parts on the page and whoever's reading can piece it together themselves.

[LegalLoliLover]

Ero is like being underground, always changing, you always have to chase the next high, create the next platform, lest you rot in censorship.

Shimoneta be like.

[warellis]

I mean the "main" TM wiki has improved a ton on that front

That's not the endgame though.

The endgame is a wiki where there is no original content at all, just primary sources.

Pure, sterile perfection. The TMdict guys got it right.

A problem I always had with the wiki is that it would claim something with a source entirely in Japanese and not translated.

Like you couldn't even trust it on sources because often the sources were untranslated.

[Lambda-Nu]

This sounds incredibly interesting. I think I'm gonna be following this to see where it goes.

[Menwearpink]

tbh I would be happy if we just worked on a new updated Seikadoc.

[Ideofago]

The fuck's that

And if it's what I think it is, is there a link somewhere?

[Rafflesiac]

The fuck's that

And if it's what I think it is, is there a link somewhere?

https://forums.nrvnqsr.com/showthrea...FOR-ANSWERS%29

[Ideofago]

Is this some high level joke I can't understand?

[Rafflesiac]

[Ideofago]

Oh, that's Seikadoc? I didn't remember it having any references to that when I read it.

[SirGauoftheSquareTable]

tbh I would be happy if we just worked on a new updated Seikadoc.

That approach has its limits, especially with searchability and reader-friendliness, at least compared to a wiki. Still, it probably should be done, and it should probably have hyperlinks up the wazzoo to all the various ToCs and mats translated here over the years.

[Menwearpink]

I'd say it has its advantages over a wiki in terms of weaving in the discussion and conclusion and understandings.

[aldeayeah]

A problem I always had with the wiki is that it would claim something with a source entirely in Japanese and not translated.

Like you couldn't even trust it on sources because often the sources were untranslated.

Non-moonruner plebs have no right to question the wisdom of the people (j/k)

[Byegod]

I'd say it has its advantages over a wiki in terms of weaving in the discussion and conclusion and understandings.

So gatekeeping?

[fumei]

....what?

Having a document that not only has the actual source but then also references posts that elaborate on the information in that source further so that MORE people can understand is surely the OPPOSITE of gatekeeping, wouldn't you agree?

[Inuhanyou]

So now because of competiton they have a reason to finally correct "shirou lives a normal life after fate route" and "the tsukhime manga ending takes place in a dream" people have infamously been trying to correct for years and years