Page 286 of 782 FirstFirst ... 186236276281284285286287288291296336386 ... LastLast
Results 5,701 to 5,720 of 15627

Thread: Create-a-Servant

  1. #5701
    アルテミット・ワン Ultimate One
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Age
    33
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    13,795
    Quote Originally Posted by Emiya Kurou View Post
    If you can't give a good reason why not, I can't add it to the list
    Because you're not trying to make a eroge that pays you bills. You're just writing something to kill time.

    or by having them be so awesome the reason doesn't matter like with Nero, and it has to be convincing and match the character
    1) the idea of genderbent Nero is still very silly, not awesome and 2) no, genderbent Nero is still very silly and not convincing at all (although I admit I only remember her being a woman because "gender doesn't matter, plus I used to crossdress").


  2. #5702
    Reading the Post Above Laith's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    9,764
    JP Friend Code
    926,172,038
    Blog Entries
    57
    Quote Originally Posted by Sherrinford View Post
    1) the idea of genderbent Nero is still very silly, not awesome and 2) no, genderbent Nero is still very silly and not convincing at all (although I admit I only remember her being a woman because "gender doesn't matter, plus I used to crossdress").
    You are silly Hey they needed a Saber look alike for EXTRA.

    Also something about Arthur being based on Romans or something. And since Arthur in Nasuland is female…

    Year 1

    Salt Corner

    Quote Originally Posted by hayate View Post
    He's the exception. We see him swimming in with the
    gold
    good
    waifus.

    He got his share of woes as with other players, but it has been overwhelmed by the sheer amount of different SSRs, both as F2P and P2P.

    I don't even wish to stand beside him as I got 2 consecutive IRs at my work the very same month after I got Jeanne.
    Quote Originally Posted by Gabriulio View Post
    Okay:

    First of all, a big FUCK YOU to everyone who got Holmes
    Second of all, a DOUBLE FUCK YOU at Laith because asahkwbebnfj,hhfshfls;
    Third of all, a TRIPLE FUCK YOU to people who quote Laith's gacha posts. THE WHOLE POINT OF HAVING HIM IN MY IGNORE LIST IS TO PREVENT THIS
    Quote Originally Posted by Aozaki-desu View Post
    fuck laith btw

  3. #5703
    アルテミット・ワン Ultimate One
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Age
    33
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    13,795
    Silly, silly, silly. (Also yes, I am silly. Sometimes.)

    On a side note that may or may not interest you (but it's interesting me and is relevant to this thread)... I just got from my trusted library a copy of the Mahabharata (the one with most pages, I just hope it's not another abridged version) and World Mythology And Legend by Anthony Mercatante... 674 pages for me aaaall to read, oh yeah.


  4. #5704
    英霊 Heroic Spirit
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    IN SPAAAAACCCE
    Age
    32
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    550
    Well this is more of a set of rules for defining what the limitations and allowances are for profiles to fit in the system.

    It is to prevent annoying questions and amateur mistakes.

    On a side note anyone who wants to can copy this for reference if they like, I am hoping others end up using it.
    Last edited by Emiya Kurou; May 23rd, 2013 at 07:07 PM.
    Quote Originally Posted by Siriel View Post
    "Gilgamesh is always right, even when he's wrong."

  5. #5705
    後継者 Successor Master of Chaos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    São Paulo, Brazil
    Age
    36
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    884
    Blog Entries
    1
    I promised myself to get this done eventually, and now it is finally finished!


    Class: Caster (Saber, Lancer, Archer, Rider)
    True Name: Brynhild
    Gender: Female
    Alignment: Chaotic Good

    STR: ***** B
    END: ***** C
    AGI: ***** B
    MGI: **** A
    LCK: *** D
    NP: **** A+

    Keywords
    KEYWORDS

    Valkyries (Battle Maidens)

    One of the most famous elements from Norse Mythology, a host of female figures that serve the Chief God Odin. Said to be proficient in both the arts of war and magic, they are often depicted as riding horses of mist and employing birds such as ravens and swans as familiars. Their duty is to bring victory in battle to those favored by heavens and then escort the souls of valorous warriors that died fighting to the halls of Valhalla.

    Now, it is a common misconception in modern times to see these Valkyries as holy beings like angels or even demi-gods in their own right. While it is true that some of them had some sort of supernatural background, these are the exceptions. Essentially, Valkyries are normal human maidens that were taken in by the gods due their outstanding talents and then turned into emissaries of heavens… a more accurate comparison would be the prophets and saints that are part of a certain widespread religion from Western culture.

    Volsunga Saga

    A saga included as part of Norse Mythology, it was written in Iceland during the late 13th Century. The work tells the story of the Volsung clan, a lineage of kings from Hunaland, a mythical country of Northern Europe. Modern academics draw a connection between the setting of the legend and the Migration Period (Volkerwanderung) between 300 and 700 A.D. Also, the German Nibelungenlied seems to have been based from the same oral tradition.


    CLASS SKILLS

    Territory Creation: A
    The technical skill to build up an advantageous encampment to oneself as a magus. Thanks to this Skill that allows to create in the shortest time a Workshop that displays the very best effectiveness on any kind of terrain condition, Caster boasts the greatest advantage in regards to defensive fights among all Servants. At A Rank, it is possible to mold a "Temple" that exceeds a Workshop.

    Item Construction: C
    The technical skill to produce devices that carry magical power. It makes possible to manufacture various tools, from items and Mystic Codes meant for battle to daily necessities. However, this Skill takes time for the production and supply of ingredients. At C Rank, most of the classic magic items can be produced.

    If a any her other Classes...
    Magic Resistance: B
    The capacity to negate or abate the effects of Magecraft. Negates Magecraft invoked with an aria of three verses or less. It is difficult to injure her even with High-Thaumaturgy and Greater Rituals.

    Riding: A+
    The technical skill to mount on vehicles. It also displays its effects on mechanized vehicles. If it is an animal, then he can manage as far as Mythical Beasts and Divine Beasts. However, this does not apply to the Dragon Species.

    Independent Action: D
    The ability to take action even without the prana supply from the Master. Convenient in cases like when the Master wants to activate a Magecraft that calls up maximum prana or when he cannot supply enough prana to the Servant. On another hand, it becomes difficult for the Master to put the Servant under his complete control. At D Rank, permanence in the current world is still impossible without a Master, but she has a greater degree of freedom than most Servants nevertheless.


    PERSONAL SKILLS

    Divine Protection: E (A+)
    A blessing from Divine Spirits, provides bonus modifiers to all saving throws. Increases her protections significantly, but it still cannot negate curses at this point. As a Valkyrie, she originally possessed the highest grade of providence, but that has been mostly reduced due to her defiance against Odin.

    Golden Rule: B
    Not the golden ratio of one's body, but rather the predestination of how much cash follows around in one's life. At B Rank, it is possible to amass a treasury suitable for someone of noble birth. This Skill originates from equipping the ring Andvarinaut.

    Pure Eyes: A
    The eyes which are seen as possessed by sages・high priests, the pupils turns blue when they are being employed. The parent’s spirituality and fruits of training is fatefully inherited by the child; a predestined heredity. Only inherited by "humans" possessing a high spirituality. Referred by her as the "eye of spákona (seeress)", Brynhild possesses a high-grade Pure Eyes that can see through the true nature of mysteries.

    Rune Magic: A
    Possession of the Magic Crest of Northern Europe - the Runes. Can use all the 24 Elder Furthark runes. Applications include the “vafrlogi” (wavering flames), a strong fire bounded-field that surrounds her Temple and prevents others from entering.

    NOBLE PHANTASM

    Sigrdrífa – Proof of a Envoy from Heavens
    Rank: B+
    Type:
    Anti-Unit
    Brynhild’s weapon-of-choice. The last memento of her golden age. Once upon a time, this was something that all Valkyries received when their training was completed and they were ready to fulfill their duties on the battlefield.

    A Conceptual Weapon that personify the idea of “to bring victory”, it holds the power to transform into the most suitable, most effective instrument for the situation at hand. Simply as a weapon, it will have a power equivalent to a C Rank Noble Phantasm, but Brynhild freely can imbue it with any special abilities・unique traits that she deems necessary. Things like a holy sword, a bow and arrow of sure-hit and a spear of exorcism are a matter of course, but it can even become defensive armaments such as shields or Mystic Codes that improve her magical abilities.

    Andvarinaut – Cursed Engagement Ring
    Rank: A+++
    Type: Anti-Unit
    A cursed ring said to bring many riches, but at the same time always cause the ruin of its possessor. The source of Brynhild’s demise, but conversely is also an item that she has a great attachment to. As the symbol of love between her and the hero Sigurd, when its true name is called the ring will summon the Heroic Spirit Sigurd to fight by Brynhild’s side. As a Servant, Sigurd has Independent Action of E- Rank and can only remain in this world for 30 turns.

    Background
    BACKGROUND

    The one revered as the greatest of the battle maidens (Valkyries), Brynhild. Coming into this world as one of the daughters of the Swedish king Budli, Brynhild was a child of seldom seen talent. Accomplished in both literary and military arts. Gifted with both intelligence and beauty. Naturally, she began to attract the eyes of many suitors as she grew up.

    But the one who claimed her first was not man, but rather god.

    Born with an outstanding spirituality and aptitude for the mystic arts, she eventually caught the attention of those in heavens and was brought in to become a Valkyrie. In the divine realm of Asgard, she was instructed in the greatest secrets thaumaturgy and became a master of runes. Due her outstanding accomplishment in all fields of her training, she gained the favor of the Chief God Odin and was elected as his most trusted emissary.

    Standing at the top of the Valkyries, Brynhild carried out her role dutifully for many years. However, one incident changed everything. Brynhild was ordered by Odin to intervene in the war between King Hjalmgunnar and King Agnar and bring victory to the former. For a Valkyrie, a command from Odin was absolute and they wouldn’t even think of disobeying him. Nevertheless, Brynhild went against his will and favored King Agnar, believing that he was more deserving.

    She incurred divine wrath because of this. As punishment for her disobedience, Odin had Brynhild stripped from her status and placed a strong curse upon her. Said curse would make her fall into a deep slumber that she could not awake by herself and then force her to marry whomever came to wake her. But because Brynhild did not wish to be wed with an unworthy man, as a last form of resistance, she raised a strong bounded-field of flames around the castle where she would be imprisoned. And thus, in the high peak of Mt. Hindarfjall, the proud Valkyrie lied waiting for the only man she knew to be capable of meeting the challenge and come for her.

    A Love that Defied Fate

    This story begins much earlier, during the halcyon days of her youth. At that time, a certain meeting took place…

    Thinking back, that was the most improbable of coincidences. Considering the paths that had been set for them, it was too unlikely for them to ever come face to face in that manner. Yet, the girl and the boy managed to cross ways as if by chance nevertheless.

    Back then, she was not yet a full-fledged Valkyrie.

    Back then, he was not yet a famous hero.

    The girl Brynhild and the boy Sigurd met as two regular adolescents and fell in love as two regular adolescents.

    In her wisdom, Brynhild alerted Sigurd against pursuing those feelings. They both had their respective fates to fulfill and could not be together without going against them. But Sigurd paid no mind to her warnings. After exchanging vows of eternal love, he entrusted her with the ring Andvarinaut and left, promising to come back for her once he had the means to make them happy together.

    Brynhild believed in those words from the bottom of her heart. From then on, she kept that love safe in her chest and continued down her path, always waiting for the day when they would meet again. When the hopeless sentence of falling into a cursed sleep was imposed onto her, Brynhild turned that promise as her last hope and lied down believing that Sigurd would be the one to come for her.

    And indeed he did.

    However, that was not the same Sigurd she had once knew. During a visit to the court of King Gjuki, the hero was served with a potion of amnesia by Queen Grimhild, who wanted to marry him with her daughter Gudrun. By the effect of the potion, Sigurd lost his memories about Brynhild and ended up accepting the offer of marrying Gudrun. Then, he took up a request of his brother-in-law Gunnar to win over Brynhild for him. Thanks once again to the magic of Queen Grimhild, Sigurd assumed Gunnar’s appearance and, after overcaming the bounded-field of fire surrounding Mt. Hindarfjall, woke up the sleeping Valkyrie so that she would accept Gunnar as her husband. At that point, Brynhild was also served with the potion of amnesia so that she would forget everything about Sigurd.

    But as if to scorn him, the curse of the ring Andvarinaut that he had unknowingly taken from Brynhild made Sigurd recover his lost memories right after he delivered her to the real Gunnar. His old love for the Valkyrie returned instantly. However, by then she was already out of his reach, while he himself was bound to his duties as Gudrun’s husband.

    In one fatidic day years later, Brynhild and Gudrun argued about who had the best husband. When Brynhild bragged about the things "Gunnar" did to win her, Gudrun revealed what she knew about the plot and that it was Sigurd who actually won her over. As proof, Gudrun gave Brynhild the Andvarinaut, which Sigurd kept it to himself.

    Feeling insulted, Brynhild went to Gunnar and falsely accused Sigurd of taking liberties with her. Gunnar, who by then had set his eyes on the dragon’s treasure possessed by Sigurd, gladly accepted the excuse to get rid of his brother-in-law. That being said, he knew that there was no chance of victory against Sigurd in a fair fight. So he joined forces with his older brother Giselher for a double betrayal.

    The two cursed Gunthorm, King Gjuki’s oldest son and heir, so that he would go into frenzy and attack Sigurd. Armed with the cursed sword Dainsleif, the mad warrior-turned (berserker) Gunthorm was a match to Sigurd. Then, as the two betrayers hoped, Gunthorm inflicted a mortal wound on Sigurd by striking on the weak point in his back and Sigurd took Gunthorm’s life in retaliation. With their death, Giselher became the heir in Gunthorm’s place and Gunnar took possession of Sigurd’s treasure.

    The legend tells that during Sigurd’s funeral, Brynhild remembered about her love for him because of the curse of the Andvarinaut. Overwhelmed by grief and guilt due having caused the demise of her beloved, she threw herself in the pyre where his body was being cremated so that they could be together in death.
    Last edited by Master of Chaos; September 18th, 2013 at 05:17 PM.

  6. #5706
    英霊 Heroic Spirit
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    IN SPAAAAACCCE
    Age
    32
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    550
    A cursory glance says you need to change the NP stat to A+++

    Does Andvarinaut materialize sigurd's NP?
    Last edited by Emiya Kurou; May 23rd, 2013 at 07:50 PM.
    Quote Originally Posted by Siriel View Post
    "Gilgamesh is always right, even when he's wrong."

  7. #5707
    アルテミット・ワン Ultimate One
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Age
    33
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    13,795
    Personally, the only hero I might accept being genderbent is Achilles. Maybe.

    -----

    Good work as always, Master of Chaos! But the ring summoning Sigurd... well, to be honest, it doesn't convince me too much...


  8. #5708
    後継者 Successor Master of Chaos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    São Paulo, Brazil
    Age
    36
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    884
    Blog Entries
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by Emiya Kurou View Post
    A cursory glance says you need to change the NP stat to A+++

    Does Andvarinaut materialize sigurd's NP?
    If there is something that I learned through Fate/Zero, is that a Servant's NP stat does have to be the same as the NP he possesses (just take a look at Iskander and Lancelot for instance).

    As for your second question, yes it can. However, most of Sigurd's NPs are pretty prana-consuming, so using them will reduce the time he can remain in this world considerably.

    Quote Originally Posted by Sherrinford View Post
    Good work as always, Master of Chaos! But the ring summoning Sigurd... well, to be honest, it doesn't convince me too much...
    Don't take it too seriously. That particularly NP is there more for the sake of being a plot device in a possible story than anything else. Something along the lines of, if either Sigurd or Brynhild were summoned for a Grail War, their plan would be to win, summon their beloved through the ring and then as the Grail to give both a new life in the present world.


    Incidentally, in the link bellow you will find an old take on Sigurd that I made. It might be fun to take a look and compare it to my Brynhild.

    http://forums.nrvnqsr.com/showthread...l=1#post610852
    Last edited by Master of Chaos; May 23rd, 2013 at 08:51 PM.

  9. #5709
    Sword of Chaos Knight of Khaos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Somewhere
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    325
    Note on my earlier Law of Genderbending comment. It was meant more or less as a joke considering how many people just genderbend Servants for no real reason(I at least do it to mine when I think it would be amusing).

    On a completely different note, I like that Brynhild a lot. Then again I love the Volsunga/Nibelungenlied.
    Quote Originally Posted by Detective Blackstone View Post
    Just embrace the trolling and enjoy it like a fine croissant.

  10. #5710
    夜魔 Nightmare
    Join Date
    May 2013
    Age
    37
    Posts
    298
    The true rule of gender bending is that the hero must be English. Nero is the exception that proves the rule because she is gender bent due to a direct relation to the English Arturia.

    Mordred? English. Francis Drake? English. Jack the Ripper? English. Frankenstein's Monster wasn't English in the story, but the writer who created that story was, so he was technicaly "born" in England, and thus English. Even our resident trap Astolfo was English according to those Italian epics.

    Just make sure your hero is a limey and you can feel free to swap his gender till the cows come home.

  11. #5711
    改竄者 Falsifier Petrikow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    9,158
    JP Friend Code
    588,925,100
    Blog Entries
    10
    Technically the knights of the round table were Welsh.

    Perhaps make it "British", which includes all of people on the British Isles (except the Irish who complain if you include them with the English).

  12. #5712
    死徒二十七祖 The Twenty Seven Dead Apostle Ancestors BlackField's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    4,966
    Blog Entries
    8
    Note, not all members of the Round Table were Welsh, Lancelot certainly wasn't. King Arthur was though but I don't think he would have considered himself Welsh, putting modern nation states identities on people from over a 1000 years ago is not the best idea.
    Last edited by BlackField; May 24th, 2013 at 05:53 AM.

  13. #5713
    Quote Originally Posted by BlackField View Post
    Note, not all members of the Round Table were Welsh, Lancelot certainly wasn't. King Arthur was though but I don't think he would have considered himself Welsh, putting modern nation states identities on people from over a 1000 years ago is not the best idea.
    And thus Lancelot wasn't genderbent, though it would have been hilarious if he had been.

  14. #5714
    Sword of Chaos Knight of Khaos's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2012
    Location
    Somewhere
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    325
    Quote Originally Posted by Sanguine View Post
    The true rule of gender bending is that the hero must be English. Nero is the exception that proves the rule because she is gender bent due to a direct relation to the English Arturia.

    Mordred? English. Francis Drake? English. Jack the Ripper? English. Frankenstein's Monster wasn't English in the story, but the writer who created that story was, so he was technicaly "born" in England, and thus English. Even our resident trap Astolfo was English according to those Italian epics.

    Just make sure your hero is a limey and you can feel free to swap his gender till the cows come home.
    Oh, then I'll be sure to post my genderbent Galahad sometime soon then. :P

    On another note, Here's my latest creation!

    As usual some creator's notes: This was made more or less because I was looking for people who would qualify for powerful Casters and this was one of the first I found and thought she'd be interesting and looking over what she could do in the myths I saw room for some Nasu-style wanking of her abilities :P Anyways, as usual let me know what you think and feel free to rip anything apart. If anyone has any suggestions I'm looking for better names/titles for her Noble Phantasms.

    Class: Caster
    Identity: Circe, the witch of Aeaea
    Gender: Female
    Alignment: Neutral Evil


    Appearance:
    Long red-violet hair, red eyes, pointed elf-like ears and an attractive physique. (Utterly basic I know so sue me, I'm feeling uncreative with descriptions at the moment).

    Personality:
    A powerful sorceress and being akin to the gods, Circe tends to act as if she is above the mortal around her. She sees humans as playthings simply there for her enjoyment. She thinks almost nothing of thsoe that fall victim to her little "games" and never seems to consider the repercussions of her actions. She does however have a strong sense of self-preservation and if she feels her life is in danger she is more than willing to put her high and mighty attitude to the side, as was the case with the Odysseus incident.

    As one who views humans as mere playthings, she is not above luring unsuspecting victims to her lair and transforming them into animals whenever she please, though is not one to do such things recklessly as she understands indulging herself too much could lead to unwanted eyes finding her.

    In the Grail War she would do anything to win, likely using her transformed victims as an extra source of energy if her Master could not provide her with the amount she would need. Though her desire for winning would be less to obtain teh Grail and more because it is something interesting to do and she feels she is more entitled to it than any mere mortal.

    Strength: D
    Agility: C
    Endurance: D
    Mana: A+
    Luck: B
    Noble Phantasm:

    Class Skills:

    Item Construction: A
    The skill to manufacture magical items. At this rank, Caster is capable of making healing potions that grant limited immortality.

    Territory Creation: A
    The skill to build a special terrain that is advantageous to oneself as a magus. Creation of a "Temple", which is superior to a "Workshop", becomes possible.

    Personal Skills:

    Divinity: A
    The daughter of the sun god Helios and the Oceanid Perse. After death she became venerated as a goddess of magic.

    High-Speed Divine Words: A
    The power to activate Thaumaturgy without the use of Magic Circuits. The language of the Age of Gods, back when words played a heavy role in spellcasting. As such, it is power long lost by modern magi. High-Thaumaturgy-level Magecraft can be cast at the speed of Single-Action spells

    Noble Phantasms:

    Name: ??? (I really have no name for this so if anyone has an idea that would be nice)
    Title: Wand of Beasts
    Type: Anti-Army
    Rank: B
    Range: 1-10
    Maximum number of targets: 50
    Effect: Circe's magic wand that grants her the power to turn men into beasts. Though, the wand's abilities go beyond simply turning men into pigs and other animals as described in her encounter with Odysseus and his crew.

    The wand can turn humans into any kind of animal Circe desires, or by expending more prana in the ritual she can instead opt to turn the victims into a Monstrous Beast, many times creating a creature that looks neither entirely man nor entirely beast. These transformations last until Circe decides to undo them, she dies or the wand is broken. Under normal circumstances Servants cannot be affected by the wand, though the magic can be strengthened inside her Reality Marble. The wand also allows her to command these beasts, and were she to lose she would find herself quite possibly becoming a snack for her now free victims.

    Name: Aeaea
    Title: Isle of the Witch
    Type: Anti-Army
    Rank: EX
    Range: 1-99
    Maximum number of targets: 100
    Effect: One of the most important pieces to the myth of Circe is her island. There she ruled over all thsoe she transformed into beasts andi t was there that she was her most powerful. She can call upon her vision of her island as a Reality Marble, her ultimate Noble Phantasm.

    Inside the Reality Marble is an exact recreation of the island of Aeaea from Circe's time and the island is surrounded by and endless ocean as far as the eye can see. Inhabiting the island are one hundred of the beasts that inhabited it during her life. These beasts range from creatures of the Monstrous Beast rank to even creatures of the Phantasmal Beast rank. These beasts, like those created with her wand, are completely under Circe's control and often seem docile at first but will quickly attack any target if their mistress orders them to.

    Another effect of the island is that it increases the power of Circe's spells while she is inside it, as well as increasing the power of her wand. An example of this increase is that while inside the Reality Marble she can use her wand even on Servants, though Servants with a high Mana rank of B or higher will not be affected and those with a rank of C are allowed a check against the transformation. As well, Circe has the ability to transform humans into creatures of the Phantasmal Beast rank while the island is active.
    Last edited by Knight of Khaos; August 1st, 2014 at 08:02 PM.
    Quote Originally Posted by Detective Blackstone View Post
    Just embrace the trolling and enjoy it like a fine croissant.

  15. #5715
    改竄者 Falsifier Petrikow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    9,158
    JP Friend Code
    588,925,100
    Blog Entries
    10
    Quote Originally Posted by BlackField View Post
    Note, not all members of the Round Table were Welsh, Lancelot certainly wasn't. King Arthur was though but I don't think he would have considered himself Welsh, putting modern nation states identities on people from over a 1000 years ago is not the best idea.
    The point is that calling them English is stupid.

    They spoke Welsh, not English.

    Whether they considered themselves "Welsh" or not is irrelevant.

  16. #5716
    死徒二十七祖 The Twenty Seven Dead Apostle Ancestors BlackField's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    4,966
    Blog Entries
    8
    Quote Originally Posted by Petrikow View Post
    The point is that calling them English is stupid.

    They spoke Welsh, not English.

    Whether they considered themselves "Welsh" or not is irrelevant.
    I bet you 5 internets that they didn't speak "Welsh". Calling them English is no less stupid than calling them Welsh, especially when lots of the actual legends call them English these days. Thats not to say it isn't wrong, they aren't English but they aren't Welsh, they were Britons.

  17. #5717
    地獄待ち Spinach's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Age
    30
    Posts
    16,094
    Blog Entries
    3
    I feel like we've had an extremely similar discussion before. Can someone just find it and link it to these two so we don't go over it again.


  18. #5718
    改竄者 Falsifier Petrikow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Posts
    9,158
    JP Friend Code
    588,925,100
    Blog Entries
    10
    Quote Originally Posted by BlackField View Post
    I bet you 5 internets that they didn't speak "Welsh". Calling them English is no less stupid than calling them Welsh, especially when lots of the actual legends call them English these days. Thats not to say it isn't wrong, they aren't English but they aren't Welsh, they were Britons.
    If by Welsh you mean modern Welsh, then of course not.

    But Welsh in a form nonetheless. The language branched off from Brythonic around the time of King Arthur, in the 6th century.

  19. #5719
    死徒二十七祖 The Twenty Seven Dead Apostle Ancestors BlackField's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    4,966
    Blog Entries
    8
    Quote Originally Posted by Arashi_Leonhart View Post
    As a term, England started roughly around the era that Arthur would've lived, but it started outside of the country it refers to and was brought in, meaning they would not necessarily have identified the area completely as such. However! The stories that you get most of Arthurian myth out of they do in fact call it England because they were written so much later (Whoever draws this sword from the stone shall henceforth be King of England). It's not so set in stone hrrrrrrrr that you can easily call it one or the other, really.
    A bunch of other posts from around there as well, where I held roughly the same view as Petrikow does now.

  20. #5720
    闇色の六王権 The Dark Six Polly's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Age
    31
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    8,207
    Blog Entries
    6
    Assuming for the sake of argument that they even existed in the first place, Arthur and his/her knights spoke Welsh in the same way that ancient Romans spoke Italian. Meaning they didn't.
    They spoke a Brythonic language ( which probably had a fair amount of words borrowed from Latin at that point ). They were Britons, not Welsh or English. "Arthur, King of the Britons", if you remember. If anything, Arthur would be Cornish, not Welsh, since most legends have him conceived in the castle of Tintagel, which is located in Cornwall.
    Yes, the Primitive Welsh language branched from Brythonic around 6th century, but so did Cornish, Cumbric and Breton languages. Britons inhabited most of Britain south of the Firth of Forth at the time, and to call Arthur and his men Welsh is simply incorrect. Please don't do it again.
    Last edited by Polly; May 24th, 2013 at 07:45 AM.
    My attempts at being a (fanfic) writer:

    Eclipse - a Saber Alter oneshot
    Requiem for a Race - Altrouge and Ortenrosse hunt the TAs ( 1/3 chapters, discontinued )
    Memories of a King - a 'Saber Origins' story ( 8/? chapters, discontiuned )
    A Small Warmth - a post UBW-Good oneshot, Saber/Rin
    Devil's Thrill - Narbareck hunts down a DAA Blackmore ( 10/10 chapters, finished )
    Boundary of Loneliness - Ryougi Shiki/Alphard Al-Shua oneshot. Lemon-flavoured

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •